E D I N B U R G H J O U R N A L O F B O T A N Y 64 (1): 51–99 (2007)
E
51
Trustees of the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh (2007)
doi:10.1017/S0960428607000765
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
(RANUNCULACEAE) WITH THREE NEW SERIES
S . N . Z I M A N 1, F . E H R E N D O R F E R 2, C . S . K E E N E R 3, W . T . W A N G 4,
S . L . M O S Y A K I N 1, E . V . B U L A K H 1, O . N . T S A R E N K O 1, B . E . D U T T O N 5,
R . P . C HAUDHARY6 & Y . K ADOTA7
The members of Anemone L. sect. Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Juz. (Ranunculaceae) are mainly
distributed in the Himalaya of North India, Nepal and Bhutan and the neighbouring
mountains of SW China at elevations between 1850 and 4800 m. Their taxonomy is
re-evaluated on the basis of a critical morphological analysis of extensive herbarium
material. The section is placed in Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus and differentiated into
three new series: ser. Obtusilobae, ser. Trullifoliae and ser. Rupestres. A conspectus, keys
to species, subspecies and varieties, descriptions of taxa, illustrations and distribution
maps are presented. Eleven species with several infraspecific taxa are recognized and their
synonymy, variability and relationships are discussed. In addition to the generally
accepted species Anemone obtusiloba, A. trullifolia and A. rupestris, we recognize the
following: A. polycarpa, A. rockii, A. geum and A. coelestina and four Chinese endemics,
A. yulongshanica, A. patula, A. subpinnata and A. subindivisa. Anemone imbricata and A.
fuscopurpurea are described but excluded from the section. The origins, morphological
differentiations and eco-geographical radiations of Anemone sect. Himalayicae are
discussed.
Keywords. Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus sect. Himalayicae, A. obtusiloba complex, new
series, phytogeography, Ranunculaceae, Sino-Himalayan region, taxonomy.
I NTRODUCTION
Anemone L. sect. Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Juz., also called the Anemone obtusiloba
D.Don complex, is one of the most difficult taxonomic groups in the genus Anemone
(Ranunculaceae Juss.), due to the uncertain number of taxa and their problematic
relationships. There have been three serious attempts to revise this complex: by
Brühl (1896), Lauener (1960) and Wang et al. (2001). However, Brühl used data
from only about 10 collections and although Lauener examined more collections, he
1
N. G. Kholodny Institute of Botany, National Academy of Sciences, Tereshchenkivska str. 2, Kiev,
01601, Ukraine.
2
Institute of Botany, University of Vienna, Rennweg 14, Vienna A-1030, Austria.
3
Pennsylvania State University, 208 Mueller Laboratory, University Park, PA 16802, USA.
4
Herbarium, Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 20 Nanxincun, Xiangshan, Beijing
100093, People’s Republic of China.
5
Department of Biology, Western Oregon University, 345 North Monmouth Avenue, Monmouth, OR
97361, USA.
6
Central Department of Botany, Tribhuvan University, Kirtipur, Kathmandu 5927, Nepal.
7
Department of Botany, National Science Museum, 4-1-1 Amakubo, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305, Japan.
52
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
dealt only with a limited number of morphological characters. More recently, Wang
et al. in the Flora of China provided a treatment of the genus Anemone which, for
the A. obtusiloba complex, included 11 species, seven subspecies and 13 varieties.
In this paper we amplify this treatment by Wang et al. on the basis of a critical
morphological analysis of extensive herbarium material, a thorough literature survey
and a discussion of the differentiation and relationships of the taxa involved. We
recognize three new series, 11 species, five subspecies and 14 varieties.
M ATERIALS
AND
M ETHODS
Our study is based mainly on c.2000 herbarium specimens received on loan from the
following herbaria: BBG, BC, BCC, BM, BRA, E, GH, K, KATH, KRA, KRAM,
KW, LE, P, PRG, US, VAB, W and WU (Holmgren et al., 1990), including 240
specimens collected in the high-mountain areas of India, Nepal and China by the
early collectors Delavay, Forrest, Handel-Mazzetti, J. D. Hooker, Kingdon-Ward,
Ludlow & Sheriff, Polunin, Potanin, Rock, Stainton et al., Thomson and T. T. Yu,
together with 60 specimens used by Lauener (1960). In addition, we have examined
the types of most species, subspecies and varieties in the section. From these
specimens about 300 flowering and fruiting samples were studied in detail, using
light and scanning electron microscopy, in order to obtain comparative data on basal
and involucral leaves, flowers and achenes.
H ISTORICAL S URVEY
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don was described (Don, 1825) from the Nepal Himalaya,
and shortly thereafter other authors published A. trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms., A.
rupestris Wall. ex Hook.f. & Thoms. and A. falconeri Thoms. (Hooker & Thomson,
1855). Later Anemone coelestina Franch. (Franchet, 1885), A. imbricata Maxim.
(Maximowicz, 1889) and A. gelida Maxim. (Maximowicz, 1890) were described from
the Himalaya and adjacent territories of China as taxa allied or closely related to A.
obtusiloba. Within the Himalayan members of the group Brühl recognized only two
species, Anemone obtusiloba and A. rupestris. He reduced the other taxa to subspecies
and regarded the recognition of Anemone falconeri as uncertain. Shortly thereafter
Finet & Gagnepain (1904) recognized four species within this complex (Anemone
obtusiloba, A. trullifolia, A. glauciifolia and A. reflexa). In his extensive revision of
Anemone Ulbrich (1906) recognized five species within the A. obtusiloba group (A.
obtusiloba, A. rupestris, A. trullifolia, A. coelestina and A. imbricata). After Ulbrich’s
revision a number of new species allied to Anemone obtusiloba were described: A.
bonatiana H.Lév. (1909), A. geum H.Lév. (1915), A. polycarpa W.E.Evans (1921), A.
rockii Ulbr. (1929), and A. ovalifolia (Brühl) Hand.-Mazz. (1931).
Overlapping and variable characters have complicated the taxonomy of the
Anemone obtusiloba complex. Pritzel (1841), who produced the first monograph on
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
53
Anemone, classified A. obtusiloba in section Anemonospermos DC. (1824).
Maximowicz (1890) placed Anemone imbricata into section Anemonanthea DC.
and A. gelida into section Omalocarpus DC. After an examination of the achene
morphology in Anemone, Janczewski (1892) classified A. obtusiloba in section
Pulsatilloides DC., together with A. glauciifolia Franch. from China, and A. capensis
L. and A. alchemillifolia E.Mey. from South Africa. Brühl (1896) regarded such a
taxonomic association as unjustified and suggested a relationship between the
groups of Anemone obtusiloba and A. narcissiflora. Moreover, Finet & Gagnepain
(1904) included Anemone gelida and A. imbricata in the same section as A.
narcissiflora.
Like Janczewski (1892), Ulbrich (1906) included the species of the Anemone
obtusiloba complex in section Pulsatilloides, but separated them as series Himalayicae
Ulbr. After examining c.160 specimens, including 30 types, from 120 localities,
Lauener (1960) noted almost continuous variation in many characters, especially of
‘sepals’ (often termed tepals in the literature, but referred to as ‘petaloids’ in this
paper), pistil and involucral leaf characters, as well as indumentum. Lauener believed
that four species within the Anemone obtusiloba complex (A. obtusiloba, A. rupestris,
A. trullifolia and A. imbricata) could be distinguished on the basis of the shape,
dissection and teeth characters of the basal leaves.
Tamura (1967) took Brühl’s opinion into consideration and consequently removed
Anemone obtusiloba and allied species from section Pulsatilloides, and re-classified
them in section Omalocarpus as subsection Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Tamura. Tamura
(1991, 1995) also followed Juzepchuk (1937) in raising the rank of section
Omalocarpus to subgenus Omalocarpus (DC.) Juz. and of subsection Himalayicae
to section Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Juz. In these publications, Tamura erroneously called
the section ‘Himalayica’, despite the original spelling ‘Himalayicae’ by Ulbrich
(1906), Juzepchuk (1937), and even by Tamura himself in his earlier publication
(Tamura, 1967).
According to Wang (1974, 1980), a total of 10 species of section Himalayicae occur
in China: the previously mentioned Anemone obtusiloba, A. rupestris, A. trullifolia
and A. rockii, and six Chinese endemics: A. patula C.C.Chang & W.T.Wang, A.
yulongshanica W.T.Wang, A. subpinnata W.T.Wang, A. liangshanica W.T.Wang, A.
lutienensis W.T.Wang and A. subindivisa W.T.Wang. However, Wang placed
Anemone imbricata in section Omalocarpus.
In North India and Nepal four species of section Himalayicae were recognized:
Anemone obtusiloba, A. rupestris, A. trullifolia and A. geum, with A. falconeri
transferred to Hepatica (Hara & Williams, 1979; Chaudhary, 1988; Sharma et al.,
1993). In addition, Hara (1973) described Anemone fuscopurpurea as a taxon allied to
A. obtusiloba which was later placed into the monotypic section Fuscopurpurea
Tarasevich & Chaudhary (1987).
According to Qureshi & Chaudhri (1978), only Anemone obtusiloba and two closely
related species, A. multisepala Qureshi & Chaudhri and A. neelamiana Qureshi &
Chaudhri, occur in Pakistan. They place these species into section Anemonanthea. In
54
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
contrast, Rechinger & Riedl (1992) maintain that Anemone obtusiloba belongs to
section Omalocarpus and that it occurs in both Pakistan and Afghanistan.
In revising the subtribe Anemoninae Spach, Starodubtsev (1989, 1991) suggested
raising section Pulsatilloides sensu Ulbrich to the status of genus, Pulsatilloides (DC.)
Starod., with several East Asian and African species. He included in this genus the
section Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Starod. with the following three species: Pulsatilloides
obtusiloba (D.Don) Starod., P. trullifolia (Hook.f. & Thoms.) Starod., and P. gelida
(Maxim.) Starod. However, he transferred Anemone imbricata to section Imbricatae
Starod. in the genus Anemonastrum Holub.
On the basis of morphological and molecular analyses Hoot et al. (1994) verified
the correct placement of the Anemone obtusiloba complex in section Omalocarpus
(‘Homalocarpus’) with five species: A. obtusiloba, A. rupestris, A. trullifolia, A.
coelestina and A. geum.
The treatment of the Anemone obtusiloba complex in the Flora of China by
Wang et al. (2001) differed from Wang (1974, 1980) in that A. liangshanica and
A. lutienensis were reduced to varieties of A. trullifolia, whereas A. coelestina, A.
geum and A. polycarpa were recognized as species.
P LACEMENT
AND
D EFINITION
OF
A NEMONE
SECT.
H IMALAYICAE
In our treatment we mainly follow Hoot et al. (1994) and Tamura (1995) in accepting
the placement of the Anemone obtusiloba complex as section Himalayicae (not
‘Himalayica’) within the subgenus Omalocarpus. Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus has
two sections: Omalocarpus and Himalayicae. Members of both sections share
numerous and mostly synapomorphic morphological characters: short, erect or
ascendent monopodial rhizomes with several axillary flowering stems (scapes),
rosulate basal leaves with vaginate petioles, sessile involucral leaves, umbellate
cymose inflorescences, a perianth of 5–8 petaloids, sessile achenes in globose or
ovoid heads and the synplesiomorphic feature of tricolpate pollen grains.
Furthermore, both sections evidently have the same and apomorphic chromosome
base number of x 5 7 (see Discussion).
In agreement with Tamura (1967, 1995) we regard the taxa in section Himalayicae
as characterized by having reduced inflorescences with only 1(2–3) flowers. In our
opinion, other diagnostic characters of this section include the three reduced sessile
involucral leaves (bracts) which are always distinctly smaller than the basal leaves,
and petaloids with 3–5(–7) basal veins, usually lacking anastomoses.
D IFFERENTIAL C HARACTERS
WITHIN THE
S ECTION
For the taxonomic differentiation of the section, we first examined c.80 morphological
characters and then narrowed down the list to 16 quantitative and 19 qualitative
features. Several quantitative characters, such as the range of basal leaf number
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
55
(mostly 5–12) or the average number of basal leaves (7–8), were too similar across the
taxa to be useful. They depend largely on the plant’s age and ecological conditions.
The same applies to the number of scapes and petaloids, the length and width of
petaloids, and the length of involucral bracts, scapes, pistils and stamens.
We consider the most important quantitative characters to be the length and width
of petioles and blades of basal leaves. These vary from blades orbicular-ovate (wider
than long) with long narrow petioles to blades oblong (longer than wide) with short,
broad, or almost absent petioles. There are great differences in the degree of leaf
division from twice 3-sect or 3-lobed with leaflets on petiolules or fused to
completely undivided leaves. Great variability is also observed with respect to the
indumentum of the basal leaves, involucral bracts, scapes and pedicels, from villous
and densely pubescent to practically glabrous. Flowers differ in many qualitative and
quantitative characters, for example in the shape of petaloids which may be obovate,
elliptic or oblong-elliptic. In addition, petaloid colour varies considerably within
most taxa and several colour variants frequently occur in the same population. For
example, flowers of whitish-blue, orange-brown, deep blue-violet, dark red, and
white with violet tinges are found in single populations of Anemone obtusiloba in the
Himalaya. Further differences between taxa exist with respect to petaloids in one or
two whorls (and then often dimorphic), in their veins and vein anastomoses, in the
presence of staminodes and in the stamens and their filaments. The quantitative
characters of achene and style length are also important. Styles may be conical,
apically straight or slightly curved and rarely even uncinate.
To summarize, the most important characters for taxonomic differentiation within
Anemone sect. Himalayicae are:
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
base of leaf blades (cordate or rounded to truncate, attenuate or cuneate)
division of leaf blades (from twice 3-sect to undivided)
leaflets (with petiolules or sessile)
inflorescences (several- or solitary-flowered)
shape of inflorescence bracts (lobed, with teeth or undivided)
petaloids (monomorphic or dimorphic)
anastomosing petaloid veins (present or absent)
shape of filaments (linear or dilated, i.e. lanceolate)
staminodes (present or absent)
achenes (ovoid or sometimes¡compressed, without or with distinct lateral ribs)
indumentum of leaves, stems, pedicels, petaloids, pistils and achenes.
C ONSPECTUS, K EY
AND
R EVISION
OF
A NEMONE
SECT.
H IMALAYICAE
The following conspectus differs from Starodubtsev (1991) and Tamura (1995) in the
circumscription of many taxa and some nomenclatural details. We recognize 11
species (with five subspecies and 14 varieties) in section Himalayicae, which occur
mainly in the Himalaya of Nepal and North India and in adjacent areas of China.
56
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
They are classified into three new series: Obtusilobae, Trullifoliae and Rupestres. For
the three narrow endemics A. patula, A. subpinnata and A. subindivisa from China
(Sichuan) no ripe achenes are yet available. Their placement into the series is still
provisional. Two other species (Anemone imbricata and A. fuscopurpurea) are briefly
described and discussed, but are excluded from section Himalayicae and the Key.
Anemone L., Sp. Pl. 538 (1753); Gen. Pl. 241 (1754). – Type: Anemone coronaria L.
Subgenus Omalocarpus (DC.) Juz., Fl. URSS 7: 256 (1937). – Type: Anemone
narcissiflora L.
Section Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Juz., Fl. URSS 7: 256 (1937). – Anemone subsect.
Brevistylae Ulbr. ser. Himalayicae Ulbr., Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 37: 201 (1906). –
Anemone subsect. Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Tamura, Sci. Rep. (Osaka Univ.) 16: 27
(1967). – Pulsatilloides (DC.) Starod. sect. Himalayicae (Ulbr.) Starod., Vetrenitsy
124 (1991). – Type: Anemone obtusiloba D.Don.
Series Obtusilobae Ziman, Ehrendorfer & Bulakh, ser. nov.
Achenia ovoidea, non compressa, sine costis lateralibus, plus minusve dense
pilosa, styli paulo flexi, 1–2.5 mm longi. Foliorum radicalium petiola 1–2(3) mm
lata, laminae in parte basali cordatae sive rotundatae, plerumque distincte
trisectae foliolis apicalibus petiolulatis, tripartitis, trilobatis sive integerrimis.
– Type: Anemone obtusiloba D.Don.
Achenes ovoid, not compressed, without lateral ribs, more or less densely pubescent,
styles slightly bent, 1–2.5 mm long. Basal leaves with petioles 1–2(3) mm wide, blades
cordate or rounded at base, mostly 3-sect with apical leaflets petiolulate, 3-parted to
3-lobed or undivided.
1. Anemone obtusiloba D.Don
A. subsp. obtusiloba
a. var. obtusiloba
b. var. potentilloides Lauener
c. var. leiophylla (W.T.Wang) Ziman, Ehrendorfer & Bulakh
B. subsp. megaphylla W.T.Wang
C. subsp. nepalensis Chaudhary
2. Anemone patula C.C.Chang & W.T.Wang
3. Anemone polycarpa W.E.Evans
4. Anemone subpinnata W.T.Wang
5. Anemone rockii Ulbr.
a. var. rockii
b. var. pilocarpa W.T.Wang
c. var. multicaulis W.T.Wang
6. Anemone geum H.Lév.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
57
Series Trullifoliae Ziman, Ehrendorfer & Bulakh, ser. nov.
Achenia ovoidea, non compressa, sine costis lateralibus, plus minusve dense
pilosa, styli erecti, 2–2.5 mm longi. Foliorum radicalium petiola (2–3)4–10 mm
lata, laminae in parte basali attenuatae, cuneatae sive truncatae, plus minusve
tripartitae foliolis sessilibus nec petiolulatis vel indivisae. – Type: Anemone
trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms.
Achenes ovoid, not compressed, without lateral ribs, more or less densely pubescent,
with straight styles 2–2.5 mm long. Basal leaves with petioles (2–3)4–10 mm wide,
blades attenuate, cuneate or truncate, more or less 3-divided or undivided, leaflets
never petiolulate.
7. Anemone trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms.
a. var. trullifolia
b. var. liangshanica (W.T.Wang) Ziman & B.E.Dutton
c. var. lutienensis (W.T.Wang) Ziman & B.E.Dutton
8. Anemone coelestina Franch.
a. var. coelestina
b. var. linearis (Brühl ex Hand.-Mazz.) Ziman & B.E.Dutton
c. var. holophylla (Diels) Ziman & B.E.Dutton
9. Anemone subindivisa W.T.Wang
10. Anemone yulongshanica W.T.Wang
a. var. yulongshanica
b. var. truncata (H.F.Comber) W.T.Wang
Series Rupestres Ziman, Ehrendorfer & Bulakh, ser. nov.
Achenia ellipsoidea, distincte compressa, costis lateralibus distinctis, plerumque glabra, styli curvati, 1.2–1.8 mm longi. Foliorum radicalium petiola 1–2 mm
lata, laminae in parte basali subcordatae, bis trisectae, foliolis petiolulatis,
foliolum apicale trisectum. – Type: Anemone rupestris Wall. ex Hook.f. &
Thoms.
Achenes ellipsoid, distinctly compressed, with lateral ribs, mostly glabrous, styles
curved, 1.2–1.8 mm long. Basal leaves with petioles 1–2 mm wide, blades basally
subcordate, twice 3-sect, leaflets petiolulate, apical leaflet 3-sect.
11. Anemone rupestris Wall. ex Hook.f. & Thoms.
A. subsp. rupestris
B. subsp. gelida (Maxim.) Lauener
Species of Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus excluded from section Himalayicae:
12. Anemone imbricata Maxim.
13. Anemone fuscopurpurea H.Hara
58
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
Key to species
1a. Achenes ellipsoid, distinctly compressed, with lateral ribs, mostly (sub)glabrous;
basal leaves with blades twice and deeply 3-sect with 3-sect apical leaflets ___
______________________________________________________ 11. A. rupestris
1b. Achenes ovoid, not (or sometimes slightly) compressed, without lateral ribs,
more or less densely pubescent; basal leaves with blades less deeply and often
only once 3-sect to 3-cleft with 3-parted to 3-lobed or undivided apical leaflets,
but leaves sometimes also completely undivided ________________________ 2
2a. Basal leaves mostly deeply divided and at least the terminal leaflets with distinct petiolules, blades basally cordate or rounded, often wider than long or as
wide as long; indumentum variable to reduced; leaf petioles only 1–2(–3) mm
wide _____________________________________________________________ 3
2b. Basal leaves more shallowly divided and the lobes without distinct petiolules, or
completely undivided, blades basally mostly attenuate, cuneate or truncate,
often longer than wide; indumentum villous to densely pubescent; leaf petioles
mostly broader and (2–)4–10 mm wide ________________________________ 8
3a. Involucral bracts mostly 3-parted to 3-dentate; scapes 1- or 2(–3)-flowered _ 4
3b. Involucral bracts undivided or partly 3-lobed; flowers solitary ____________ 6
4a. Bases of basal leaves rounded, apical leaflets with petiolules 10–15 mm long;
staminodes present; achene styles uncinate ________________ 3. A. polycarpa
4b. Bases of basal leaves cordate (rarely subtruncate), apical leaflets with shorter
petiolules; staminodes absent; achene styles straight or slightly curved _____ 5
5a. Apical leaflets on petiolules 1–2 mm long, lateral leaflets subsessile; scapes 1–
3-flowered; filaments linear _____________________________ 1. A. obtusiloba
5b. Apical leaflets with petiolule only 0.5–1 mm long; flowers solitary; filaments
lanceolate ________________________________________________ 2. A. patula
6a. Basal leaves longer than wide, apparently pinnatifid, apical leaflets 3-sect, on 3–
5 mm long petiolules, lateral leaflets subsessile, unequally 3-parted; petioles of
basal leaves 2–5 cm long _______________________________ 4. A. subpinnata
6b. Basal leaves about as long as wide, mostly 3-sect to 3-cleft, apical leaflets 3lobed or undivided; petioles of basal leaves 5–20 cm long _______________ 7
7a. Apical leaflets with petiolules 1–2 mm long; petaloids dimorphic, 10–20 6 6–
12 mm; filaments sublinear (0.3–0.5 mm wide) ________________ 5. A. rockii
7b. Apical leaflets with petiolules 5–10 mm long; petaloids all similar, 5–12 6 4–
9 mm; filaments lanceolate (0.5–1 mm wide) __________________ 6. A. geum
8a. Blades of basal leaves with attenuate base; scapes 1–3-flowered; petaloids
sometimes with anastomosing veins __________________________________ 9
8b. Blades of basal leaves with truncate base; flowers solitary; petaloids without
anastomosing veins _______________________________________________ 10
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
59
9a.
Blades of basal leaves 3-parted to 3-lobed, rhombic-ovate to obovate;
involucral bracts 3-lobed or 3-dentate; scapes 1–3-flowered; involucral bracts
mostly 3-lobed or 3-dentate; filaments ovate-lanceolate _____ 7. A. trullifolia
9b. Blades of basal leaves weakly 3-lobed to undivided, oblong-linear to
oblanceolate; involucral bracts undivided; flowers solitary; filaments
linear ______________________________________________ 8. A. coelestina
10a. Blades of basal leaves undivided or obscurely 3-lobed; involucral bracts entire
or 3-dentate; petaloids 5–10 6 5–8 mm, with 3–5 veins ___ 9. A. subindivisa
10b. Blades of basal leaves mostly 3-parted or 3-lobed; involucral bracts 3-lobed;
petaloids 8–16 6 8–10 mm, with 3 veins ____________ 10. A. yulongshanica
1. Anemone obtusiloba D.Don, Prodr. Fl. Nepal 194 (1825). – Anemone obtusiloba
D.Don subsp. obtusiloba (typica) Brühl, Ann. Roy. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78
(1896). – Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. genuina Ulbr., Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 37:
242 (1906). – Type: Hab. In Gosaingsthan Nepaliae, Wallich s.n. (lecto BM,
designated here by Ziman and Mosyakin). Figs 1, 18.
Anemone govaniana Wall., Numer. List 166: 4688 (1831), nom. nud., non Lindl. (1844).
– The specimen of A. obtusiloba annotated as A. govaniana India, 10–11000 ft, Herb.
Falconer 29 is deposited at K in a type folder.
Anemone mollis Wall., Numer. List 166: 4689 (1831), nom. nud.
Anemone discolor Royle, Ill. Bot. Him. Mount. 11: 52 (1839). – Type: NW India,
Himalayae Alpibus. Choor-Urukta et Kendarkanta supra 10000 pedes elevatis,
Royle (lecto LIV).
Anemone micrantha Klotzsch, Bot. Ergebn. Reise Waldemar 133 (1862). – Anemone
obtusiloba D.Don subsp. micrantha (Klotzsch) Ulbr., Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 37: 242
F I G . 1. Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. obtusiloba. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a,
petaloid; b, stamen; c, carpels); C, achene (A–B, Potanin 1872, LE; C, Grey-Wilson & Philips
471, K). Scale bars (applies to Figs 1–17): A 5 1 cm; B–C 5 1 mm.
60
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
(1906). – Type: Not designated. We have examined the likely syntypes Duthie s.n.
from Kashmir (K), Potanin s.n. from Kansu (LE) and Delavay s.n. from Yunnan
(LE).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. coerulea Ulbr., Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 37: 242 (1906). –
Type: Kashmir, Falconer 29 (lecto K!, designated here).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. chrysantha Ulbr., Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 37: 242 (1906). –
Type: Tibet, Kardang, Hans (lecto K!, designated here).
Anemone rupestris Hook.f. var. villosa Marquand & Shaw, J. Linn. Soc. 48: 154
(1929). – Type: Tibet, Nyima La, 3960–4270 m, in open pastures in the
Rhododendron shrub belt, 22 vi 1924, Kingdon-Ward 5821 (holo K!).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. polysepala W.T.Wang, Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 169
(1974). – Type: China, Yunnan, Weisi, 3780 m, 29 v 1940, Feng 4270 (holo PE!).
Anemone multisepala Qureshi & Chaudhri, Pakistan Syst. 2: 15 (1978). – Type: NW
Pakistan, Chitral Distr., Gujargol near Lowari Pass, Bioban, Lowari Top, 17 vii
1977, Shah & Khan 2439 (holo ISL).
Anemone neelamiana Qureshi & Chaudhri, Pakistan Syst. 2: 15 (1978). – Type: Azad
Kashmir, Muzaffarabad Distr., Upper Neelam Valley, Dudgai, 3800 m, 28 vi
1978, Iqbal & Abbasi 1827 (holo ISL).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. leiocarpa Tamura, Acta Phytotax. Geobot. 37: 153
(1986). – Type: Nepal, Bhojpur Distr., Salpa-Bhanjyang-Charapani, 3320 m, 26 vi
1976, Tabata 10924 (holo KYO!).
Basal leaves 5–10 (rarely to 20); petioles 3–15(–20) cm 6 1–2 mm, villous or
pubescent; blades 3-sect (sometimes 3-parted or 3-lobed), reniform-pentagonal to
broadly ovate, 2–6 6 2–10 cm, densely spreading villous to sparsely pubescent or
sometimes abaxially subglabrous; bases cordate (rarely subtruncate); leaflets (or
lobes) overlapping or remote; apical leaflets of 3-sect leaves on petiolules 1–2 mm
long, 3-parted, 3-cleft, or 2- to 3-lobed, rarely undivided, rhombic-ovate to broadly
rhombic, subequal or larger than lateral leaflets; with margins obtusely or acutely
dentate; lateral leaflets subsessile, unequally 2- or 3-parted or 2- or 3-lobed, obliqueflabellate to ovate (Fig. 1A). Scapes 2–5, 5–25(–35) cm long, spreading-villous or
pubescent, 1- or 2(–3)-flowered. Involucral bracts 3-parted, 3-cleft, 3-lobed or 3dentate (rarely undivided), broadly rhombic, rhombic-obovate, oblong-ovate,
lanceolate, or cuneate, 1–3 cm long, appressed pilose. Pedicels 1–3(–5) cm long,
appressed pilose. Petaloids 5–7, obovate or elliptic, white, bluish or yellowish, 5–15
6 3–8 mm, abaxially pilose; basal veins 3–5, anastomosing veins absent (rarely
solitary) (Fig. 1Ba). Staminodes absent. Stamens 2.2–3 mm long; filaments linear,
slightly narrowed apically, 0.5–0.8 mm long; anthers ellipsoid, connectives narrow
(Fig. 1Bb). Carpels ovoid, 1.2–2 mm long, usually villous or sometimes subglabrous,
hairs 0.5–1 mm long; styles straight or curved, 0.5–1.5 mm long (Fig. 1Bc). Achenes
broadly ovoid, rarely slightly compressed, but without ribs, 3–6 6 2–3.5 mm,
densely strigose, softly pubescent or subglabrous (hairs 0.6–1.6 mm long); styles
apically hooked or substraight, 1–2.5 6 1–1.5 mm (Fig. 1C).
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
61
Distribution and habitat. Afghanistan, Pakistan, Kirgizstan, Mongolia, W and SW
China (NW Yunnan, SW Sichuan, E and S Xizang, Gansu, Shanxi, Sikang), North
India (Kumaon, Simla, Punjab, Kashmir), Nepal, Bhutan, Burma (Fig. 18). In
forests, at forest margins, meadows and alpine grassland; 1850–4800 m.
Nomenclatural notes. In the protologue of Anemone obtusiloba Don (1825) cites the
locality and collection/collector information as ‘Hab. In Gosaingsthan Nepaliae.
Wallich.’. We studied several specimens collected by Wallich, of which only the BM
specimen has a label closely corresponding to the protologue data: ‘Gosaingsthan
Nepalensium, Wallich s.n.’ (BM!). The plant itself is undoubtedly Anemone
obtusiloba, but the specimen bears no notes made by Don, and thus its identity as
the holotype is questionable. In the Kew herbarium (K) the folder with ‘type
specimens’ contains several herbarium sheets. We select here the BM specimen as the
lectotype of Anemone obtusiloba.
Taxonomic remarks. Don (1825) characterized Anemone obtusiloba as having 3-sect
villous basal leaves with cuneate bases, incised-crenate margins and obtuse terminal
lobes, 3-lobed involucral leaves, solitary flowers, 5 obovate petaloids, and pubescent
achenes. Hooker (1872) noted the variability of Anemone obtusiloba, especially with
respect to the size, colour and villosity of flowers and shape of basal leaves.
Consequently, he suggested that there might be several infraspecific taxa. Brühl
(1896) confirmed the evident variability within Anemone obtusiloba and was the first
author to devise an infraspecific classification that included six subspecies and five
varieties. In addition to Anemone obtusiloba subsp. obtusiloba (5 ‘typica’), Brühl
recognized six others: subsp. trullifolia (with three varieties: var. linearis, var.
spatulata and var. rotundifolia), subsp. coelestina, subsp. ovalifolia (with two
varieties: var. geochares and var. orthocaula), subsp. saxicola, subsp. omalocarpella
and subsp. imbricata. The first three subspecies (subsp. trullifolia, subsp. coelestina
and subsp. ovalifolia) later were accepted as separate species (see below), whereas
subsp. saxicola was discussed by Lauener (1960: 198) under A. rupestris, and subsp.
omalocarpella (Wang et al., 2001: 323) under A. polycarpa. According to Ulbrich
(1906), Anemone obtusiloba consists of two subspecies and two varieties: subsp.
obtusiloba (5 ‘genuina’) and subsp. micrantha (differing mainly in size), and vars.
coerulea and chrysantha (differing mainly in petaloid colour). Lauener (1960),
however, recognized three subspecies: subsp. obtusiloba (with two varieties: var.
obtusiloba and var. potentilloides), subsp. ovalifolia, and subsp. rockii which differ
mainly in their leaf shapes. Wang (1974, 1980) differentiated five infraspecific taxa of
Anemone obtusiloba in China: subsp. obtusiloba and subsp. ovalifolia (as above), and
in addition subsp. megaphylla, subsp. leiophylla and var. polysepala. According to
Wang, subsp. megaphylla and subsp. leiophylla differ from subsp. obtusiloba in their
basal leaves; and var. polysepala by its more numerous petaloids.
Hara & Williams (1979) noted that in Nepal Anemone obtusiloba was represented
by subsp. obtusiloba and subsp. omalocarpella. Tamura (1986) described Anemone
obtusiloba var. leiocarpa from Nepal (endemic to the Bhojpur District), which
62
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
differed from subsp. obtusiloba in its more or less compressed, slightly marginate,
glabrous or sparsely hispid carpels. However, Chaudhary (1988) considered that in
Nepal there were four subspecies of Anemone obtusiloba: the forementioned subsp.
obtusiloba, subsp. omalocarpella and subsp. potentilloides, but also the new subsp.
nepalensis, which he differentiated by leaf and flower characters. Anemone obtusiloba
was considered by Qureshi & Chaudhri (1978, 1988) to include two varieties (var.
obtusiloba and var. potentilloides). In addition they described two endemics from
Pakistan, Anemone multisepala and A. neelamiana, closely related to A. obtusiloba.
Anemone multisepala was stated to differ from A. obtusiloba in having narrowly
obovate-cuneate leaflets and smaller but more numerous yellow petaloids, and from A.
neelamiana in having white flowers with 8 petaloids. More recently Thothathri & Uniyal
(1982) and Riedl & Nasir (1991) reduced these recently described Pakistani species to
synonymy under Anemone obtusiloba due to the considerable overlapping variability.
Our analysis leads us to agree with Lauener (1960) in recognizing Anemone
trullifolia as a distinct species and not as a subspecies of A. obtusiloba. However, we
treat Anemone rockii and A. geum (5 A. ovalifolia) not as subspecies but as species.
We also agree with Lauener in regarding Anemone discolor and A. micrantha as
synonyms of A. obtusiloba as there are no distinct characters to separate them. With
respect to Anemone multisepala and A. neelamiana, we follow Thothathri & Uniyal
(1982) and Riedl & Nasir (1991) in regarding these as synonyms of A. obtusiloba. In
our opinion, Anemone obtusiloba subsp. saxicola and Anemone obtusiloba subsp.
omalocarpella should be included in A. rupestris due to the similarity of their basal
leaves and especially their achenes. Anemone obtusiloba subsp. leiophylla and
Anemone obtusiloba subsp. potentilloides should rather be treated as varieties because
of their weak distinguishing characters. Thus, we recognize three subspecies in
Anemone obtusiloba: subsp. obtusiloba (with two varieties, var. leiophylla and var.
potentilloides), subsp. megaphylla and subsp. nepalensis, whose differences are given
in the following key.
Key to subspecies and varieties
1a. Petioles of basal leaf blades 15–20 cm long; leaf blades 3–6 6 4–10 cm, sparsely
pubescent; scapes 25–35 cm long; petaloids 5, 10–15 6 5–10 mm ___________
________________________________________________ 1B. subsp. megaphylla
1b. Petioles of basal leaf blades 3–15 cm long; leaf blades 1–6 6 1–8 cm, pubescent
or villous; scapes mostly less than 20 cm long; petaloids 5–7, 7–12 6 4–8 mm 2
2a. Scapes only up to 10 cm long; basal leaves with blades 1.5–2.5 6 2.5–3.5 cm,
pubescent, with acute teeth _________________________ 1C. subsp. nepalensis
2b. Scapes usually longer than 10 cm; basal leaves with blades up to 4 6 6 cm, often
villous and with obtuse teeth. 1A. subsp. obtusiloba _____________________ 3
3a. Basal leaves densely spreading-villous, mostly with obtuse teeth ____________
__________________________________________________ 1Aa. var. obtusiloba
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
63
3b. Basal leaves pubescent, often with acute teeth __________________________ 4
4a. Petaloids blue; basal leaves with obtuse to acute teeth, apical leaflets 3lobed _________________________________________ 1Ab. var. potentilloides
4b. Petaloids white; basal leaves with acute teeth, apical leaflets 3-sect __________
___________________________________________________ 1Ac. var. leiophylla
1A. subsp. obtusiloba
Petioles of basal leaves 5–15 cm long; blades mainly 3-sect, sometimes 3-parted to 3lobed, broadly ovate or reniform-pentagonal, usually obtusely dentate, 1–4 6 1–6 cm,
densely spreading-villous to sometimes sparsely pubescent; apical leaflets 3-lobed to
3-cleft, rhombic-ovate. Scapes 5–20 cm long. Involucral bracts 3-parted to 3-lobed or
sometimes 3-dentate, rarely undivided, rhombic to cuneate, 1–2 cm long. Petaloids
5–7, white, blue or yellowish, 8–12 6 3–8 mm.
Distribution and habitat. As the species.
1Aa. var. obtusiloba
Petioles of basal leaves 5–12 cm long; blades 3-sect, broadly reniform-pentagonal,
obtusely dentate, 2–4 6 2–6 cm, densely spreading-villous; apical leaflets 3-lobed,
rhombic-ovate. Scapes 5–20 cm long. Involucral bracts 3-parted to 3-lobed, rhombic
or cuneate. Petaloids 5–7, white, blue or yellowish, 8–12 6 5–8 mm.
Distribution and habitat. As the species.
Selection of herbarium specimens. AFGHANISTAN. Nuristan: Kamdesh, 2800 m, 22 vi 1959, Gilli
766 (W).
PAKISTAN. NW Frontier: Hazara Distr., Murree Hills, 15 vi 1955, Webster & Sack 5719 (K);
Mukshpuri, 2500 m, 3 v 1970, Ecker 19737 (W); Hazara, Pipe Line, 31 v 1975, Chaudhri &
Qureshi 306 (W); Chitral Distr., Gujargol near Lowari Pass, Bioban, Lowari Top, 17 vii 1977,
Shah & Khan 2439 (ISL).
MONGOLIA. 1895, Przewalski s.n. (without geographic details and number) (LE); Archengsi,
Cecerle Ich-Tamir, 1850 m, 26 vi 1978, Knapp 233179 (LE).
CHINA. Yunnan: Ca-long-pin, 18 vii 1889, Delavay s.n. (LE); Lidjiang [Likiang], Mt.
Yulung-Schan, vi 1914, Handel-Mazzetti 4078 (WU); Djinscha-djiang [Yangtze], Landsangdjiang [Mekong], Lenago, 4050 m, 7 vi 1916, Handel-Mazzetti 8856 (WU); Likiang, eastern
slopes of Likiang Snow Range, 25 vi 1922, Rock 4767 (W); Chung-tien, Mts. West Hsiao
Chung-tien, v 1932, Rock 24666 (K). Sichuan: Da-Dsian lu (Tatsien-lou, Tarsando), 18 v 1893,
Potanin s.n. (LE); Mts. of Kulu, Muli Territory, 1932, Rock 23953 (K). Kansu: T’ao River
basin, alpine meadows, vi 1925, Rock 12254 (K); Terra Tangutorum, 14 vii 1872, Potanin s.n.
(LE); Reg. Tangutica, 1873, Plantae a Przewalski collectae (E); ibid., 1880 (E, LE); Valle
Runwyz, 1885, Potanin s.n. (LE); Berg Shao Wu Taishan, Waldgreuse, vii 1879, Moellendorf
612 (WU). Xizang: Montes Tala-gui, 4 vi 1884, Przewalski 92 (LE); Rija simitra, 11 vi 1884,
Przewalski 123 (LE); Kam, Djagyn-gol, 1900, Ladygyn 25 (LE); Dohpa, 13–14000 ft, 15 vii
1900, Ladygyn 264 (LE); 17 vii 1900, Ladygyn 645 (LE); Entok-gomba, 11500 ft, 26 iv 1901,
Ladygyn 25 (LE).
64
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
NEPAL. Yarpang, 16000 ft, 10 viii 1932, Sharma 3415 (BM); Jumla, 7500 ft, 4 v 1952,
Polunin et al. 906 (K); Gandak Kosi Watershed, 12000 ft, 5 v 1953, Proud 150 (BM); Chhairo
gaun, North of Tukucha, 10000 ft, 2 vi 1954, Stainton et al. 877 (BM); Ankhu Khola, Barand,
10200 ft, 5 vi 1962, Bowes-Lyon 103 (BM); Bagmati Zone, Gossain Kurda, 3000 m, 8 v 1967,
Nicolson 3299 (BM); Dolpo Valley, 5 mi East of Ting Kyu, 4800 m, 2 viii 1973, Grey-Wilson &
Philips 471 (K); Purangaun, above Garunga, North of Parbat, 2700 m, 4 v 1976, Wormald 116
(BM).
BHUTAN. Phaksana, 10500 ft, 6 vi 1971, Ramesh Bedi 68 (E).
INDIA. Kashmir: Keslitoar, 10000 ft, Thomson 4688 (K); Simla La, 13–14000 ft, 22 i 1924,
Kingdon-Ward 5821 (BM); Apharwat, 12000 ft, 12 viii 1956, Polunin 56/220 (BM); Gulmarg,
above Khelanmarg, 30 v 1971, Robson 1911 (BM); Upper Chenab: Pangi Valley, 23 v 1881,
Ellis 1141 (WU); Dehra Dun, Kulu Valley, 8 vi 1949, Basa s.n. (W); Kulu Valley, Pulga, 17 vi
1950, Jain & Bharadwaja s.n. (W); Simla Hill State: Punjab, Kamru, Baspa Valley, 13000 ft, 26
vi 1939, Sheriff 7345 (BM); Simla, Huttoo, 10000 ft, 20 v 1956, Chiddall 38 (BM).
KIRGIZSTAN. Tien-Shan: Upper part of the basin of Sary-Dzhas, close river Kaska-Ter, 3 vii
1902, Sapozhnikov s.n. (LE); Semirechenski Distr., close Przewalski, river Tjuz, 3 vii
1912, Sapozhnikov s.n. (LE); Basin of Sary-Dzhas, close river Gjuz, 15 vii 1959, Zviagina s.n.
(LE).
1Ab. var. potentilloides Lauener, Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 23: 187 (1960). –
Type: supra Shupien, in herbosis excelsissimus, Jacquemont 665 (holo K!; iso
BM!). – Anemone potentilloides Cambess. ex Besant, Gard. Chron. 177: 371 (1927),
nom. subnud. – Anemone obtusiloba subsp. potentilloides (Lauener) Chaudhary,
Bot. Zhurn. 73: 1188 (1988).
Petioles of basal leaves 5–8 cm long; blades mainly 3-sect, reniform-pentagonal,
obtusely to acutely dentate, 1–3 6 1–2 cm, pubescent; apical leaflets 3-lobed,
broadly rhombic. Scapes 10–20 cm long. Involucral bracts mostly 3-lobed, oblongrhombic, 1–2 cm long. Petaloids 5–6, blue, 8–12 6 4–8 mm.
Distribution and habitat. India (Himachal Pradesh, Lahul, Kashmir), Pakistan
(Chitral, Hazara) (Fig. 18); 2700–4000 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. INDIA. Kashmir: Apharwat, 12000 ft, 12 viii 1956, Polunin
56/220 (BM); Gulmarg, above Khelanmarg, 30 v 1971, Robson 1911 (BM).
PAKISTAN. NW Frontier: Hazara Distr., Murree Hills, 15 vi 1955, Webster & Sack 5719 (K);
Mukshpuri, 2500 m, 3 v 1970, Ecker 19737 (W); Hazara: Pipe Line, 31 v 1975, Chaudhri &
Qureshi 306 (W).
1Ac. var. leiophylla (W.T.Wang) Ziman, Ehrendorfer & Bulakh, stat. nov. – Anemone
obtusiloba D.Don subsp. leiophylla W.T.Wang, Fl. Reipubl. Popul. Sin. 28: 350
(1980). – Type: China, NW Yunnan, Gongshan Drung-Nu Zu Zi Zhixian, 1938,
T.T. Yu 22076 (holo PE!).
Petioles of basal leaves 5–12 cm long; blades 3-sect, reniform-pentagonal, acutely
dentate, 1–4 6 2–6 cm, sparsely pubescent; leaflets remote, apical 3-cleft, broadly
rhombic. Scapes 8–25(–35) cm long. Involucral bracts 3-dentate or undivided,
oblong-rhombic, 1–2 cm long. Petaloids 5–7, white, 7–12 6 3–7 mm.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
65
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan) (Fig. 18). At forest margins and on grassy
slopes; 2900–3000 m. Endemic of NW Yunnan (Gonshan Drung-Nu-Zi Zhixian).
Known only from the type collection.
1B. subsp. megaphylla W.T.Wang, Fl. Reipubl. Popul. Sin. 28: 350 (1980). – Type:
China, SW Yunnan, Chengkang, Snow Range, grassy slopes, 3400 m, 24 vii 1938,
T.T. Yu 16956 (holo PE!).
Petioles of basal leaves 15–20 cm long; blades 3-parted, reniform-pentagonal, acutely
dentate, 3–6 6 4–10 cm, sparsely pubescent; lobes overlapping, apical leaflet 3-cleft,
broadly rhombic. Scapes 25–35 cm long. Involucral bracts 3-lobed, rhombic or
rhombic-obovate, 2–3 cm long. Petaloids 5, blue, 10–15 6 5–10 mm.
Distribution and habitat. China (SW Yunnan: Zhenkang Xian) (Fig. 18), on grassy
slopes; c.3400 m.
Known only from the type collection.
1C. subsp. nepalensis Chaudhary, Bot. Zhurn. 73: 1188 (1988). – Type: Nepal,
Jaljale, 3500 m, 23 vi 1979, Sajiu & Tuladhar s.n. (holo KATH!).
Petioles of basal leaves 3–5 cm long; blades 3-sect, rhombic-ovate, 1.5–2.5 6 2.5–
3.5 cm, pubescent, margins acutely dentate, apical leaflets 3-parted. Scapes 5–10 cm
long. Involucral bracts 3-sect, ovoid, 1–1.2 cm long. Petaloids 5, white, basally
bluish, c.10 6 8 mm.
Distribution and habitat. Central Nepal (Okhaldhunga, Dhading, Baglung) (Fig. 18);
3500 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. NEPAL. Okhaldhungagaon, South of Dhorpatan, 10000 ft, 1
v 1954, Stainton et al. 350 (BM), 374 (BM), 376 (BM); Jaljale, 3500 m, 23 vi 1979, Sajiu &
Tuladhar s.n. (KATH!).
2. Anemone patula C.C.Chang ex W.T.Wang, Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 169 (1974). –
Type: China, Central Sichuan, Li Xian, 3500 m, 14 vi 1936, K.L. Chu 2796 (holo
E!). Figs 2, 19.
Basal leaves 5–9; petioles 3–10 cm 6 c.1 mm, subglabrous; blades 3-sect, orbicularovate, 0.5–3.5 6 1–4 cm, sparsely pubescent or glabrescent, bases deeply cordate;
leaflets subsessile; apical leaflets 3-lobed, flabellate-rhombic, lobes flabellateobovate, margins lobulate, lobules narrowly ovate, sometimes denticulate; lateral
leaflets 3-lobed, obliquely flabellate (Fig. 2A). Scapes 3–6, 5–25 cm long,
subglabrous; flowers solitary. Involucral bracts 3-lobed to 3-dentate, rarely
undivided, obovate, 1–2 cm long, puberulent or subglabrous. Pedicels 2–5 cm long,
puberulent or subglabrous. Petaloids 5(–6), white or blue-purple, ovate or broadly
66
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
F I G . 2. Anemone patula C.C.Chang ex W.T.Wang var. patula. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a,
stamen; b, carpel) (A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
obovate, 4–12 6 2–9 mm, puberulent, basal veins 3–7, anastomosing veins absent.
Stamens 3–5 mm long; filaments lanceolate (Fig. 2Ba). Carpels 2–4 mm long, villous
(Fig. 2Bb). Achenes unknown.
Distribution and habitat. China (Sichuan) (Fig. 19). In Abies forests and in thickets;
3500–3530 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Wang (1974) described Anemone patula as a species allied to A.
rupestris but differing in the shape of the basal leaflets (subsessile and 3-lobed), larger
petaloids and strongly villous carpels. Based on these characters, but also on its
solitary flowers and lanceolate filaments, Anemone patula is closer to A. obtusiloba
and keys out in series Obtusilobae. Additional study is needed in this species due to
the limited herbarium material and lack of data on achenes. Wang (1980) recognized
two varieties of Anemone patula, var. patula and var. minor, which differ in scape and
leaf size, and the size, colour and villosity of the flowers. These varieties were later
accepted by Wang et al. (2001).
Key to varieties
1a. Petaloids white or blue-purple, 8–12 6 5–9 mm; scapes 10–25 cm long; leaf
blades 1–3.5 6 1.5–4 cm _______________________________ 2a. var. patula
1b. Petaloids white, 4–6 6 2–3 mm; scapes 5–10 cm long; leaf blades 0.5–1 6 1–
2 cm __________________________________________________ 2b. var. minor
2a. var. patula
Leaf blades 1–3.5 6 1.5–4 cm. Scapes 10–25 cm long. Petaloids white or blue-purple,
8–12 6 5–9 mm.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
67
Distribution and habitat. Central Sichuan (Li Xian). In Abies forests; 3500 m.
Known only from the type collection.
2b. var. minor W.T.Wang, Fl. Reipubl. Popul. Sin. 28: 350 (1980). – Type: China,
Sichuan, Baoxing Xian, 3530 m, 1936, K.L. Chu 923 (holo PE!).
Leaf blades 0.5–1 6 1–2 cm. Scapes 5–10 cm long. Petaloids white, 4–6 6 2–3 mm.
Distribution and habitat. Central and western Sichuan (Baoxing Xian, Jinchuan
Xian). In thickets; 3530 m.
Known only from the type collection and a few specimens collected in the same area
and cited in the protologue.
3. Anemone polycarpa W.E.Evans, Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 13: 154 (1921).
– Anemone rupestris subsp. polycarpa (W.E.Evans) W.T.Wang, Fl. Reipubl.
Popul. Sin. 28: 43 (1980). – Type: China, Yunnan, ‘Mekong-Salween divide. Alt.
12000 ft, ix 1914, Forrest 13320’ (holo E!). Figs 3, 19.
Anemone rupestris Wall. ex Hook.f. & Thoms., Fl. Ind. (1855), pro parte (excl. type).
Leaves 5–12, petioles 5–12 cm 6 c.1 mm, sparsely puberulent; blades twice 3-sect,
ovate, 3–5 6 2–4 cm, sparsely puberulent, bases rounded; apical leaflets on petiolules 10–15 mm long, 3-parted, broadly ovate; lateral leaflets on petiolules 3–5 mm
long, 3-lobed, ovate (Fig. 3A). Scapes 2–5, 5–20 cm long, 1–3-flowered, sparsely
puberulent. Involucral bracts 3-parted, obovate-rhombic, 1–3 cm long, puberulent.
Petaloids 5–6(–7), monomorphic, reddish-white, ovate-elliptic, 7–14 6 4–9 mm,
F I G . 3. Anemone polycarpa W.E.Evans. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a, petaloid; b,
staminode; c, stamen; d, carpel); C, achene (A, Flora of China, 2001; B, Forrest 20738, E; C,
Stainton et al. 5403, WU).
68
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
sparsely puberulent, basal veins 3–5, anastomosing veins absent (Fig. 3Ba).
Staminodes present (Fig. 3Bb). Stamens 3–4 mm long; filaments linear (Fig. 3Bc).
Carpels up to 80, long ellipsoid, 3–3.5 mm long, villous, styles hooked (Fig. 3Bd).
Achenes fusiform, compressed, 3–4 6 2–2.5 mm, sparsely puberulent along medial
line, hairs dimorphic (c.1 mm and 0.3 mm long); ribs absent; styles apically thickened
and uncinate, 1–4 6 1.5 mm (Fig. 3C).
Distribution and habitat. China (NW Yunnan, Sichuan, SE Xizang), Nepal, North
India (Assam), Bhutan (Fig. 19). On grassy and rocky slopes; 3500–4800 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Anemone polycarpa was described as a species close to A.
obtusiloba (Evans, 1921), but differing mainly in the pinnatisect basal leaf lobes,
numerous hairy carpels, and achenes with uncinate styles. Lauener (1960), however,
proposed to reduce it to a synonym of Anemone rupestris, and both Wang (1980) and
Chaudhary (1988) treated it as A. rupestris subsp. polycarpa (W.E.Evans)
W.T.Wang. Sharma et al. (1993) regarded Anemone polycarpa as a distinct species
and Wang et al. (2001) accepted this status but they included in it A. saxicola (Brühl)
Tamura & Kitamura based on A. obtusiloba D.Don subsp. saxicola Brühl. Our
examination of the holotype (Forrest 13320) from Yunnan, and also Stainton et al.
5403 from Nepal, suggests that Anemone polycarpa differs from A. rupestris in the 3parted involucral bracts, larger monomorphic puberulent petaloids, narrower
filaments, presence of staminodes, less compressed but more elongate achenes
without ribs and with few dimorphic hairs, and apically thickened uncinate styles.
Consequently, we regard this taxon as a species which is closer to Anemone
obtusiloba than to A. rupestris.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. NW Yunnan: Mekong-Salween Divide, vi 1921,
Forrest 19578 (K); Doker-la, Mekong, Salween Divide, ix 1921, Forrest 20738 (E); Mekong,
Salween Divide, Sila, 4000 m, 16 viii 1938, T.T. Yu 22374 (E); Upper Kjukiang Valley
(Clulung), South of Lungtsahmura, 3800 m, 10 viii 1938, T.T. Yu 1958 (E). Sichuan:
Dongregro, 4500 m, 21 vii 1922, Smith 3262 (BM); Sung pan hsien, 8 viii 1928, Fang 4063 (E).
Qinghai: Maqin Xian, Dawu Xiang, 3500 m, 31 vii 1993, T.N. Ho & Bartolomew 618 (BM).
NEPAL. Central Nepal: Bhurungdi, Khola, 22 v 1954, Stainton et al. 5403 (WU); Lamjung
Himal, 4500 m, 13 ix 1954, Stainton et al. 6326 (BM, E); South of Bhubnjeng Kharka, 3400 m,
9 viii 1974, de Haas 2137 (BM); Sagarmatha Zone, Solukhumbu Distr., Pike Peak, 3560 m,
Miyamoto et al. 84048 (BM).
INDIA. Assam: Tha Chu Valley, 11000 ft, 9 vii 1950, Kingdon-Ward 19594 (BM).
BHUTAN. Shing Be Me La, 10500 ft, 16 v 1949, Ludlow & Sheriff 20639 (BM).
4. Anemone subpinnata W.T.Wang, Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 170 (1974). – Type:
China, Szechuan: Mu-li, Wachin, Ching-chang, 3750 m, 21 vi 1937, T.T. Yu 6512
(holo PE!). Figs 4, 19.
Leaves 4–7, petioles 2–5 cm 6 1–2 mm, villous; blades apparently pinnatifid, but
in principle 3-sect, elliptic, c.2.5 6 1.8 cm, densely pubescent, bases subcordate
or broadly cuneate; apical leaflets with petiolules 3–5 mm long, 3-sect,
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
69
F I G . 4. Anemone subpinnata W.T.Wang. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a, stamen; b, carpel)
(A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
rhombic-obovate, margins incised-dentate with secondary leaflets 3-parted; lateral
leaflets subsessile, unequally 3-lobed, obliquely cuneate (Fig. 4A). Scapes 2–5, 3–
10 cm long, villous, 1-flowered. Involucral bracts subequally 3-lobed, elliptic-ovate to
oblong-ovate, c.1 cm long; lobes entire or apical lobes 3-dentate, puberulent, apically
obtuse. Pedicels 1–4 cm long, puberulent. Petaloids 5, white, tinged blue, purplish
or violet, elliptic-obovate, 5–8 6 4–6 mm, villous, basal veins 3–5, anastomosing
veins absent. Stamens 2–4 mm long; filaments linear (Fig. 4Ba). Carpels cylindric,
2.7–3.2 mm long, villous; styles curved (Fig. 4Bb). Achenes unknown.
Distribution and habitat. China, endemic of SW Sichuan, Muli, Wachin (Fig. 19). In
alpine meadows; 3700 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Wang (1974) described this species as a narrow endemic from
Sichuan, taxonomically close to Anemone obtusiloba but differing in its subpinnate
basal leaf blades, solitary flowers and strongly villous carpels. According to our data,
Anemone subpinnata differs from A. obtusiloba also in its wider basal leaf petioles,
entire (sometimes 3-lobed) involucral bracts, and linear filaments. Additional studies
are needed due to the lack of data on achenes and the limited herbarium material
available.
Known only from the type collection and a few specimens collected in the same area
and cited in the protologue.
5. Anemone rockii Ulbr., Notizbl. Bot. Gart. Berlin-Dahlem 10: 876 (1929). –
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. rockii (Ulbr.) Lauener, Notes Roy. Bot. Gard.
Edinburgh 23: 188 (1960). – Type: China, SW Kansu, southern slopes of Minshan,
South of Shimen, in crevices of limestone cliffs, along streams, 10600 ft, vi 1925,
Rock 12520 (lecto K!, designated here by Ziman and Mosyakin; iso E!). Figs 5, 20.
Leaves 5–15; petioles 5–20 cm 6 3 mm, sparsely puberulent or glabrescent; blades 3sect, broadly ovate, 2.5–5 6 2.5–5 cm, glabrous or abaxially sparsely puberulent,
bases cordate; apical leaflets on petiolules 1–2 mm long, 3-lobed, broadly ovate or
rhombic, lobes incised lobulate; lateral leaflets subsessile, unequally 2- or 3-lobed,
70
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
F I G . 5. Anemone rockii Ulbr. var. rockii. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a, petaloid; b, stamens;
c, carpel); C, achene (A, Flora of China, 2001; B, Forrest 30471, BM; C, Polunin 906, E).
obliquely flabellate; lobes and lobules contiguous, overlapping or remote (Fig. 5A).
Scapes 2–10, 10–30 cm long, glabrous or sparsely puberulent; flowers solitary.
Involucral bracts undivided or 3-lobed, obovate, 1–3 cm long, margins dentate or
entire. Pedicels 2–6(–10) cm long, puberulent. Petaloids 5(–6–9), dimorphic, white,
blue (rarely purplish), oblong-obovate, 10–20 6 6–12 mm, sparsely puberulent or
glabrous, basal veins 3–5, anastomosing veins solitary or absent (Fig. 5Ba). Staminodes sometimes present. Stamens 4–5 mm long; filaments sublinear, 0.3–0.5 mm
wide (Fig. 5Bb). Carpels 2.8–3.5 mm long, cylindric, densely or sparsely puberulent;
styles straight (Fig. 5Bc). Achenes ovoid, slightly compressed, 3–4 6 1–1.5 mm,
glabrous or sparsely to densely pubescent (hairs c.1 mm long); styles slightly bent,
1.3–1.4 mm long (Fig. 5C).
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan, Sichuan, Gansu, Xizang), Nepal (Fig. 20).
On grassy slopes; 2100–4000 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Anemone rockii was separated from A. obtusiloba by Ulbrich
(1929) on the basis of several collections made by Rock in SW Kansu, western
China, which had more robust stems, more divided basal leaves with a deeper sinus
and larger flowers. Having examined syntypes from K and BM, we note that
Anemone rockii differs from A. obtusiloba also by its wider basal leaf petioles,
subglabrous leaf blades, solitary flowers, undivided or 3-lobed involucral bracts,
subglabrous usually dimorphic petaloids, linear staminodes, and densely pubescent
achenes with slightly bent styles. We believe these distinctions merit recognizing
Anemone rockii as a distinct species. According to Wang (1980) and Wang et al.
(2001), Anemone rockii consists of three varieties. Although the majority of plants
throughout the distribution of this species belong to Anemone rockii var. rockii,
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
71
several plants from SW China with remote basal leaf blade lobes and distinctly
pubescent achenes have been recognized as distinct varieties, var. pilocarpa
W.T.Wang and var. multicaulis W.T.Wang, differing in the number and colour of
their petaloids.
Key to varieties
1a. Leaf blade lobes and lobules contiguous or overlapping; achenes glabrous or
subglabrous ____________________________________________ 5a. var. rockii
1b. Leaf blade lobes and lobules remote; achenes densely pubescent __________ 2
2a. Petaloids 8–9, white __________________________________ 5b. var. pilocarpa
2b. Petaloids 5–6, white or blue __________________________ 5c. var. multicaulis
5a. var. rockii
Basal leaf blade lobes and lobules contiguous or overlapping. Petaloids 7–8, white or
purplish. Achenes glabrous or subglabrous.
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan, Sichuan, Gansu, Xizang), Nepal (Fig. 20).
On grassy slopes; 2100–4000 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. Yunnan: Distr. of Chung-tien, 13000 ft, v 1932, Rock
24666 (BM). Sichuan: Distr. of Tchen-keou-tin, Farges s.n. (P); top of Mt. Wa, vii 1903,
Wilson 3052 (K). Kansu: Upper Tebbu County, southern slopes of Minshan, South of Shimen
in crevices of limestone clifts along streams, 10600 ft, vi 1925, Rock 12408 (BM), 12487 (BM),
12520 (K); gravelly slopes at foot of Shimen, 12000 ft, vii–viii 1925, Rock 13061 (BM, E, K);
Minshan near Djirakana Shimen limestone crevices, x 1925, Rock 13626 (BM, E, K). Xizang:
Mt. Kenichumpo, Salween and Irawady Divide, 14000 ft, vi 1932, Rock 21952 (BM), 21953
(BM).
NEPAL. West Nepal: Chankheli Lagna, 30 iv 1952, Polunin et al. 4345 (E); Saldanggaon, v
1952, Polunin et al. 16 (E); Jumla, v 1952, Polunin et al. 906 (E); Pansala, vi 1952, Polunin et al.
880 (E); Myagdi, Dara, 20 vi 1952, Polunin et al. 4344 (E); Lete Kali Gandaki, 20 iv 1954,
Stainton et al. 581 (E). East Nepal: Uttar Ganga, iv 1954, Stainton et al. 969 (E); Baglurg,
South of Dhorpatan, v 1954, Stainton et al. 356 (E); Prangburg, vi 1954, Stainton et al. 877 (E).
5b. var. pilocarpa W.T.Wang, Fl. Reipubl. Popul. Sin. 28: 350 (1980). – Type: China,
Yunnan, Chengkou Xian, 2100 m, 27 viii 1935, C.C. Chang 2064 (holo PE!).
Basal leaf blade lobes and lobules remote. Petaloids 8–9, white. Achenes densely
pubescent.
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan: Chengkou Xian). On grassy slopes; 2100 m.
Nomenclatural notes. Plants of this taxon were collected by C. C. Chang in 1935. He
initially annotated them as ‘A. pseudo-rockii sp. nova’, but this name was never
published. In 1980 Wang published it as Anemone rockii var. pilocarpa.
Known only from the type collection.
72
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
5c. var. multicaulis W.T.Wang, Fl. Reipubl. Popul. Sin. 28: 350 (1980). – Type:
China, Sichuan, Xichang Shi, 3000 m, 1977, W.T. Wang 40171 (holo PE!).
Basal leaf blade lobes and lobules remote. Petaloids 6, white or blue. Achenes
densely pubescent.
Distribution and habitat. China (SW Sichuan: Xichang Shi). On grassy slopes;
3000 m.
Known only from the type collection.
6. Anemone geum H.Lév., Bull. Acad. Int. Geogr. Bot. (Le Mans) 25: 25 (1915). –
Anemone bonatiana var. geum (H.Lév.) H.Lév., Cat. Pl. Yun-Nan 219 (1917). –
Type: China, Yunnan, lagune du haut plateau de Ta-Hai-Tse, 3200 m, v 1912,
Maire s.n. (holo E!). Figs 6, 19.
Anemone obtusiloba Franch., Plantae Delav. 8 (1889), non D.Don (1825).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. ovalifolia Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78
(1896). – Anemone ovalifolia (Brühl) Hand.-Mazz., Symb. Sin. 7: 315 (1931).
– Anemone geum H.Lév. subsp. ovalifolia (Brühl) Chaudhary, Bot. Zhurn. 73: 1188
(1988). – Type: NW China, Yunnan, Yungning, Handel-Mazzetti 3157 (holo WU!)
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. geochares Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78
(1896). – Type: China, Regio Tangutorum (N Tibet), 1880, Przewalski s.n. (lecto
LE!, designated here by Ziman; iso E).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. orthocaula Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78
(1896). – Type: India, Kumaon near the Lebung pass, 14–15000 ft, 1 viii 1886,
Duthie 5272 (holo BM!; iso LE!).
Anemone wardii Marquand & Shaw, J. Linn. Soc. 48: 154 (1929). – Type: Tibet,
Doshong La, Pemako, 25 x 1924, Kingdon-Ward 6262 (holo K!).
F I G . 6. Anemone geum H.Lév. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a, petaloid; b, staminodes; c,
stamen; d, carpel); C, achene (A–B, Handel-Mazzetti 6671, WU; C, Smith 10642, BM).
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
73
Anemone rupestris Hook.f. var. pilosa Marquand & Shaw, J. Linn. Soc. 48: 154
(1929). – Type: Temo La, 4270 m, in pastures among dwarf Rhododendron on the
open moorland, 6 vi 1924, Kingdon-Ward 5747 (holo K!).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. ovalifolia Brühl var. polysepala W.T.Wang, Fl.
Reipubl. Popul. Sin. 28: 43 (1980). – Type: China, NW Yunnan, 3780 m, 29 vii
1970, Feng 4070 (holo PE!).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. ovalifolia Brühl var. angustilimba W.T.Wang, Fl.
Reipubl. Popul. Sin. 28: 43 (1980). – Type: China, SW Sichuan, 25 viii 1936, W.T.
Wang 660929 (holo PE!).
Basal leaves 5–15, petioles villous, 3–15 cm 6 2–3 mm; blades ovate, 3-sect or
sometimes 3-parted, 2–5 6 2–5 cm, densely long hairy or sparsely short hairy; bases
subcordate or subtruncate; apical leaflets of 3-sect leaves on petiolules 5–10 mm
long, 3-lobed or undivided, broadly rhombic, longer (sometimes much) longer than
lateral leaflets which have petiolules 1–3 mm long and are 2- or 3-lobed (Fig. 6A).
Scapes 2–5, 5–25 cm long, villous or pubescent; flowers solitary. Involucral bracts
undivided or 3-lobed, 1–2 cm long, puberulent. Pedicels 1–2(–6) cm long, puberulent.
Petaloids 5(–8), broadly ovate, white, yellowish, mauve or blue, 5–12 6 4–9 mm,
abaxially pubescent; basal veins 3(–5), anastomosing veins absent (Fig. 6Ba).
Staminodes sometimes present, c.2 mm long (Fig. 6Bb). Stamens 2–3 mm long;
filaments lanceolate, 0.5–1 mm wide (Fig. 6Bc). Carpels narrowly ovoid, 2–3 mm
long, pubescent or subglabrous, hairs 0.5–0.7 mm long; styles straight, 0.5–1.5 mm
long (Fig. 6Bd). Achenes ovoid, sometimes slightly compressed, 3–4.8 6 1.6–2.3 mm,
villous or subglabrous, hairs 0.8–1.3 mm long; styles straight, 1.8–2.6 mm long (Fig.
6C).
Distribution and habitat. Pakistan, China (Quinghai, NW Yunnan, W Sichuan,
Xizang, S Xinjiang), Nepal, North India (Assam, Himachal Pradesh, Uttaranchal,
Sikkim) (Fig. 19). In scrub and alpine meadows; 1900–4800 m.
Chaudhary (1988) reported the occurrence of this taxon in Bhutan (without
localities) and in Burma (Shan, Mt. Victoria) but we were unable to find any
herbarium collections from these localities.
Taxonomic remarks. Brühl (1896) described typical Anemone obtusiloba subsp.
ovalifolia as having ovate 3-sect basal leaf blades and slightly compressed hirsute or
glabrous pistils and achenes. He recognized two varieties, var. geochares and var.
orthocaula, which differ in having prostrate-procumbent or erect-ascendent scapes,
respectively. Several years later Léveille (1915) described plants from China
(Yunnan) having characters similar to ‘ovalifolia’ of Brühl as Anemone geum
H.Lév. Shortly afterwards he (Léveille, 1917) reduced it to Anemone bonatiana var.
geum. Handel-Mazzetti (1931) then described plants with ovate 3-sect basal leaf
blades from Yunnan as Anemone ovalifolia (Brühl) Hand.-Mazz. by raising Bruhl’s
variety to specific status. Under this name he included Anemone rupestris var. lobata
and A. obtusiloba subsp. micrantha Ulbr. pro parte based on the similar shape of the
74
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
basal leaves. Later Lauener (1960) reinstated this taxon as Anemone obtusiloba
subsp. ovalifolia and treated A. geum as its synonym. Wang (1974, 1980) also
considered Anemone geum as a synonym of A. obtusiloba subsp. ovalifolia, but
recently Wang et al. (2001) accepted A. geum as a distinct species with two
subspecies, subsp. geum and subsp. ovalifolia. After examination of specimens from
Nepal and India, Hara & Williams (1979) and Sharma et al. (1993) recognized
Anemone geum and included A. ovalifolia as a synonym. Chaudhary (1988)
considered Anemone geum to include two subspecies, subsp. geum and subsp.
ovalifolia, which, although occurring in the same area, differed mainly in rhizome
shape and the pubescence of the basal leaves. According to the results of our
examination of the type specimens of Anemone geum (Maire from Yunnan) and A.
ovalifolia (Handel-Mazzetti from Yunnan), plus examination of other herbarium
specimens (mainly from K, BM and E), we confirm the morphological similarity of
these plants and believe all of them belong to A. geum. The species name by Léveille
(1915) has priority over the combination A. ovalifolia (Brühl) Handel-Mazzetti
(1931). Despite our recent recognition of Anemone geum subsp. geum and A. geum
subsp. ovalifolia (Wang et al., 2001), here we reject these taxa. Wang (1980)
recognized three varieties within Anemone geum (albeit using the name A. obtusiloba
subsp. ovalifolia): var. ovalifolia, var. polysepala and var. angustilimba. Variety
polysepala was described as differing from the other varieties by its greater number
of petaloids and was distinguished further from var. angustilimba by the shape of its
basal leaf blades. Following our examination of the type specimens of Wang’s var.
polysepala (Feng 4070) and var. angustilimba (W.T. Wang 660929), we regard all
these ‘differential’ characters as too variable to be of taxonomic significance.
Therefore we conclude that it would be better to recognize A. geum as a species
without distinct subspecies and varieties.
Selection of herbarium specimens. PAKISTAN. Prov. Frontiere, Gittidas au Katawai, 4100 m, 15
vii 1953, Schmidt 445 (BM).
CHINA. Yunnan: Close to Yungning, 3140 m, 23 vi 1914, Handel-Mazzetti 2730 (WU);
Likiang, Mt. Julung Shan, 6 ix 1914, Handel-Mazzetti 661 (WU), 4080 (WU); Yulung Shan,
Mt. Nguluho, 3400 m, 7 vi 1915, Handel-Mazzetti 6671 (WU); Haba and Dugwantsum, SE of
Chung tien, 4350 m, 23 vi 1915, Handel-Mazzetti 6908 (WU); eastern slopes of Mt. Dyinaloko,
North Peak of the Likiang Snow Range, 13000 ft, vi 1923, Rock 9016 (W); Likiang Snow
Range, 3780 m, 29 vii 1970, Feng 4070 (PE). Sichuan: Mts. Daliang Shan (territory Lolo), East
of Ningyuen, South Dsilimba, 3275 m, 26 iv 1914, Handel-Mazzetti 1757 (WU); Fumadia and
Wolo-ho, close to Yenyuen and Yungning, 3300 m, 15 vi 1915, Handel-Mazzetti 3065 (WU);
South of Tschescha and North of Yungning, close to monasterium Muli, 3800 m, 24 vi 1915,
Handel-Mazzetti 7179 (WU); close to Doko, and South of Yungning, monasterium Muli, 4350 m,
4 viii 1915, Handel-Mazzetti 7405 (WU); Sung-pan, 3000 m, 6 vii 1922, Fang 2624 (E); 9 vii 1922,
Smith 2448 (BM); Sungpan-hsien, 8 viii 1928, Fang 4068 (E); Hsioeh-shan, 4300 m, 19 vii 1932,
Smith 3885 (BM); Hsioeh-Shan, 25 viii 1936, W.T. Wang 660929 (PE). Shansi: Yang ling kie
(Ou t’ai chan), 30 vi 1922, Licent 6556 (BM). Chindu: Xian, Qingshuine Xiang, between Madou
and Yushu, 4300 m, 11 viii 1996, T.N. Ho et al. 1613 (BM). Qinghai: Tongde Xian, Longmuer
Xiume, between Jungong (Gyumgo) and Hebei, North side of Hung He, 3650 m, 22 vii 1993, T.N.
Ho et al. 156 (BM); Maqin (Magen) Xian, Dawu Xiang, along Gegu He, 3500 m, 31 vii 1993, T.N.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
75
Ho et al. 618 (BM). Xizang: Doshong La, Pemako, 3050 m, 25 x 1924, Kingdon-Ward 6262 (K);
Radja and Yellow River Gorges, 13000 ft, vi 1926, Rock 14105 (E), vi 1926, Rock 14196 (BM, E);
Tsarung, Solo-la, alpine belt, 14500 ft, vi 1932, Rock 22245 (BM, E). Xinjiang: Kangting
(Tachienlu), 3100 m, 15 vii 1934, Smith 10462 (WU); Yulingkong, Gomba La, 3700 m, 22 vii 1934,
Smith 10701 (BM).
NEPAL. East Nepal: Largeng Khola, 14500 ft, 21 vi 1950, Lowndes 1038 (BM); Sangda:
North of Tukucha, 19 viii 1954, Stainton et al. 7316 (BM); Basia: Banjang, 4700 m, 6 viii 1973,
Einarsson et al. 2728 (BM); Close to Dhorpatan, North side of Uttar Ganga, 3800 m, 3 iv
1974, Vickery 554 (BM); Cha Lundgpa, 15300 ft, 29 vii 1977, Miehe 391 (E), 393 (E).
INDIA. Uttaranchal: Kutti Yangti Valley, 15000 ft, 1 viii 1886, Duthie 5272 (WU). Assam:
Tulung La, 1935, Kingdon-Ward 11681 (BM); Luguthang, 12000 ft, Kingdon-Ward 11622
(BM).
7. Anemone trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms., Fl. Ind. 1: 22 (1855). – Anemone obtusiloba
D.Don subsp. trullifolia (Hook.f. & Thoms.) Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5:
78 (1896). – Anemone trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms. var. typica Finet & Gagnep.,
Bull. Soc. Bot. France 11: 61 (1904). – Type: East Himalaya, Hab. Sikkim. Regio
alpina, 11–15000 ft, 14 vii 1849, Hooker s.n. (lecto K!, second step designation here
by Ziman and Mosyakin; iso E!). Figs 7, 20.
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. trullifolia (Hook.f. & Thoms.) Brühl var.
spatulata Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78 (1896). – Types: Brühl reported
several type localities and specimens: ‘Sikkim (H. f. and others), near Thaling,
Tsumtong (King’s collectors!); Chumbi: on Pit-ze-la, Pan-ka-la, Oey-gung-la;
Phari (King’s collectors!); Bhutan; N. W. Himalaya?’, without numbers and data
on herbarium (probably CAL). As we have not seen these plants, we are unable to
designate a lectotype.
F I G . 7. Anemone trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms. var. trullifolia. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a,
petaloid; b, stamen; c, carpel); C, achene (A–B, Handel-Mazzetti 7179, WU; C, Smith & Cave
1711, E).
76
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. trullifolia (Hook.f. & Thoms.) Brühl var.
rotundifolia Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78 (1896). – Type: Sikkim, near
Thaling, 13000 ft, and in other localities (Cunningham, G. Gammie, King’s
collectors!). Like var. spatulata, we have not seen any of these plants.
Anemone chumulangmaensis W.T.Wang, Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 171 (1974). – Type:
China, Tibet, Mons Chumulangma, Kama, 4380 m, 15 vi 1959, Exped. ad Montem
Chumulongma 269 (holo PE!).
Leaves 4–10; petioles flat, 1–3(–5) cm 6 3–5 mm, villous or densely pubescent, rarely
puberulent; blades 3-parted to 3-lobed, spathulate, rhombic-obovate to obovate, 2–7
6 1–5 cm, villous or densely pubescent, bases attenuate (sometimes cuneate),
margins distally dentate, apices rounded (Fig. 7A). Scapes 2–7, 3–15(–20) cm long,
villous or densely pubescent, 1–3-flowered. Involucral bracts 3-lobed or 3-dentate,
sometimes entire, narrowly obovate or lanceolate, 1–2.5 cm long, hirsute. Bracteoles
sometimes present, small, paired. Pedicels 1–5(–8) cm long, pubescent or puberulent.
Petaloids 5–6(–15), monomorphic or sometimes dimorphic (if more than 6), white,
yellow, pinkish, purplish or blue, elliptic-obovate, 5–12(–15) 6 4–8(–10) mm, densely
or sparsely pubescent, hirsute or villous, anastomosing veins 1–2(–3) or sometimes
absent (Fig. 7Ba). Stamens 1.8–3.4 mm long; filaments ovate-lanceolate, 0.5–0.7 mm
wide (Fig. 7Bb). Carpels cylindric-ovoid, 2–4 mm long, villous or pubescent (Fig. 7Bc).
Achenes ellipsoid-ovoid or fusiform, slightly compressed, 3.2–4.4 6 1.6–2.2 mm,
without ribs, villous, hairs c.1 mm long; styles straight, 2–2.6 mm long (Fig. 7C).
Distribution and habitat. SW China (NW Yunnan, S Sichuan, SW Gansu, S
Quinghai, S Xizang), East Nepal, India (Sikkim), Bhutan (Fig. 20). In forests and
alpine meadows; 2500–4800 m.
Nomenclatural notes. Hooker and Thomson cited two collections (syntypes) in the
protologue: ‘Sikkim, alt. 11–15,000 ft, Hooker f.; and Bhotan, Griffith’. Specimens of
the respective collections are deposited at K and E. Lauener (1960) cited the E
specimens (‘Sikkim: 3350–4570 m, J.D.Hooker’ and ‘Bhutan: Griffith 1718’) as
syntypes, while Chaudhary (1988) cited as a type the first specimen mentioned by
Lauener (Hooker’s specimen ‘Sikkim, 3350–4570 m, J.D.Hooker’, but from K),
which can be regarded as an effective lectotypification. However, in that citation
Chaudhary changed feet to metres and failed to indicate the collection date explicitly
identifying the lectotype. Since there are several of Hooker’s specimens representing
at least two collections (‘Hab. Sikkim. Regio alpina. Alt. 11–15000 ped., 14 vii 1849
and 5 ix 1849. Coll. J.D.Hooker. Herbarium Hookerianum 1867’), we have made the
second step lectotypification of one of these.
Taxonomic remarks. Anemone trullifolia was described from the eastern Himalaya as
a taxon very close to A. obtusiloba (Hooker & Thomson, 1855). Brühl (1896)
recognized Anemone trullifolia as a subspecies of A. obtusiloba and also made A.
coelestina, a species which had recently been described by Franchet (1885), another
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
77
subspecies of A. obtusiloba. However, he did not note any differences between these
two taxa except for the yellow or blue petaloid colour and the distribution (Anemone
trullifolia in the Himalaya and A. coelestina in SW China, Yunnan). Brühl noted the
differences in basal leaf shape within subspecies trullifolia and on this basis he
described three varieties: var. linearis (with mainly linear entire leaves), var. spatulata
(with short-spathulate 3-lobed leaves) and var. rotundifolia (with suborbicular 3lobed leaves). Anemone trullifolia and A. coelestina were maintained by Ulbrich
(1906) under the former name as one ‘species collectiva’. In contrast, Finet &
Gagnepain (1904) proposed two varieties for Anemone trullifolia, var. coelestina and
var. souliei, and Diels (1912) recognized var. campestris and var. holophylla within
this taxon. Lauener (1960), however, again separated Anemone trullifolia and A.
coelestina as distinct species and distinguished them by the shape of the basal leaves
and the hairiness of the pistils. Furthermore, within Anemone trullifolia, he
recognized var. trullifolia, var. linearis and var. holophylla, differentiated on the
basis of leaf shape. Wang (1974) described three narrow endemics close to Anemone
trullifolia: A. chumulangmaensis W.T.Wang, A. liangshanica W.T.Wang and A.
lutienensis W.T.Wang. Anemone chumulangmaensis was lumped with A. trullifolia
var. trullifolia by Wang himself and we agree with this. Furthermore, after examining
the type materials of Anemone liangshanica and A. lutienensis we have reduced both
to varieties of A. trullifolia (Figs 7, 8 and 9).
Key to varieties
1a. Leaf blades 3-lobed, ovate or broadly lanceolate; scapes 1–3-flowered; petaloid
anastomosing veins 1–3 _______________________________ 7a. var. trullifolia
1b. Leaf blades 3-parted or 3-cleft, spathulate or rhombic; flowers solitary; petaloid
anastomosing veins absent __________________________________________ 2
2a. Leaf blades 3-parted, spathulate; petaloids 7–9 6 5–6 mm, villous __________
__________________________________________________ 7b. var. liangshanica
2b. Leaf blades 3-cleft, rhombic; petaloids 9–13 6 6–8 mm, sparsely pubescent __
___________________________________________________ 7c. var. lutienensis
7a. var. trullifolia
Leaf blades 3-lobed, ovate or broadly lanceolate. Scapes 1–3-flowered. Petaloids 5–7,
anastomosing veins 1–3.
Distribution and habitat. China (NW Yunnan, SW Sichuan, S Xizang), Nepal, India
(Sikkim, Himachal Pradesh), Bhutan (Fig. 20). Along streams in forests and in
alpine meadows; 2500–4500 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. Yunnan: Long-Ki, 1894, Delavay s.n. (WU); v 1906,
Bailey (LE); Likiang Range, 1933, McLawrens 307 (BM); Xiao huadinba, above Farm, v 1981,
SBEC 747 (E). Sichuan: Mts. [near] Muli, vii 1930, Forrest 28434 (BM); Mountains round
78
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
Muli, vii 1930, Forrest 28484 (BM); ibid., 1931, Forrest 30041 (BM), 30471 (BM), 30817 (BM).
Xizang: Mons Chumulangma, Kama, 4380 m, 15 vi 1959, Exped. Mt. Chumulangma 269 (PE).
NEPAL. Jansala, 3000 m, 17 v 1973, Einarsson et al. 53 (BM).
INDIA. Sikkim: Regio alpina, 11–15000 ft, 14 vii 1849, Hooker s.n. (E, K); Llonok, 15000 ft,
22 ix 1909, Smith & Cave 1711 (E); Zemu and Lhonakh Valleys, Yeumtang, 12000 ft, 13 ix
1947, Cave 167 (E); Himalaya: Jolinka, 14500 ft, vii 1931, Bentham s.n. (BM). Himachal
Pradesh: Chamba, below Sathraundi, Bera Nullah, 10000 ft, 8 vi 1981, Sayers 3689 (BM).
BHUTAN. 1867, Griffith 1718 (E, K); Mem La, Paro Valley, 13000 ft, 15 v 1949, Ludlow &
Sheriff 16247 (BM, E); Mangde Chu, 14000 ft, 12 vi 1966, Bowes-Lyon 3440 (BM); Waitang,
Isampa, 15000 ft, 2 vi 1949, Ludlow et al. 19202 (BM); Cho La, 12500 ft, 4 vii 1949, Ludlow
et al. 20800 (BM).
7b. var. liangshanica (W.T.Wang) Ziman & B.E.Dutton, Fl. China 6: 324 (2001). –
Anemone liangshanica W.T.Wang, Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 170 (1974). – Type:
China, Sichuan, Lepo, Liangshan, Hwangmaokeng, 2800 m, 19 vi 1959, C.C. Hu
et al. 761 (holo PE!). Fig. 8.
Leaf blades 3-parted, spathulate. Flowers solitary. Petaloids white or purplish, 7–9
6 5–6 mm, villous; anastomosing veins absent.
Distribution and habitat. China. Endemic to western Sichuan, Lepo (5 Leibo Xian)
(Fig. 20). In alpine meadows; 3000–3600 m.
Known only from the type collection and a few specimens collected in the same area
and cited in the protologue.
F I G . 8. Anemone trullifolia var. liangshanica (W.T.Wang) Ziman & B.E.Dutton. A, leaf; B,
flower parts (a, stamen; b, carpel) (A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
79
F I G . 9. Anemone trullifolia var. lutienensis (W.T.Wang) Ziman & B.E.Dutton. A, basal leaf;
B, flower parts (a, stamen; b, carpel) (A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
7c. var. lutienensis (W.T.Wang) Ziman & B.E.Dutton, Fl. China 6: 324 (2001). –
Anemone lutienensis W.T.Wang, Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 170 (1974). – Type:
China, Yunnan, Lichiang, Lutien, 28 v 1939, R.C. Ching 20548 (holo PE!). Fig. 9.
Leaf blades 3-cleft, rhombic. Petaloids white or blue, 9–13 6 6–8 mm, sparsely
pubescent; anastomosing veins absent.
Distribution and habitat. China. Endemic to NW Yunnan (Lichiang, Lutien) (Fig.
20). In alpine meadows; 4000 m.
Known only from the type collection and a few specimens collected in the same area
and cited in the protologue.
8. Anemone coelestina Franch., Bull. Soc. Bot. France 32: 4 (1885). – Anemone
obtusiloba D.Don subsp. coelestina (Franch.) Brühl, Ann. Roy. Bot. Gard.
Calcutta 5: 78 (1896). – Anemone trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms. var. coelestina
(Franch.) Finet & Gagnep., Bull. Soc. Bot. France 51: 61 (1904). – Type: China,
Prov. Yunnan, sommet du mont Hee-chan-men, supra Lan-Kong, 2 vi 1884,
Delavay 3 (lecto P!, designated here by Ziman and Mosyakin). Figs 10, 20.
Anemone bonatiana H.Lév., Feddes Repert. Spec. Nov. 7: 98 (1909). – Type: China,
Yunnan: Lao Kouy-Chan, pres My Le, 1906, Herb. Bonati, Ngueou 607 (holo E!).
Leaves 5–10; petioles 1–4 cm 6 8–10 mm, villous or densely pubescent; blades
subtrilobed to undivided, oblong-linear to oblanceolate, 2–8 6 1–3 cm, villous,
bases cuneate-attenuate; margins obtusely or acutely dentate (Fig. 10A). Scapes 2–8,
3–10 cm long, densely pubescent; flowers solitary. Involucral bracts undivided, linearlanceolate, 1–3 cm long, villous. Pedicels 1–3 cm long, villous. Petaloids 5–6,
monomorphic, reddish blue or bluish white, yellow, reddish orange, reddish violet or
80
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
F I G . 10. Anemone coelestina Franch. var. coelestina. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a, petaloid;
b, stamen; c, carpel); C, achene (A, Delavay 1887, WU; B, Handel-Mazzetti 2437, WU; C,
Forrest 1922, LE).
bluish violet, broadly elliptic, 8–14 6 7–12 mm, densely pubescent, basal veins 3–5,
anastomosing veins absent (sometimes solitary) (Fig. 10Ba). Stamens 2.5–3 mm long;
filaments linear (Fig. 10Bb). Staminodes absent or occasionally present. Carpels
ovoid, 3–4 mm long, villous; styles straight (Fig. 10Bc). Achenes ovoid, 3–4.5 6 2 mm,
without ribs, villous, hairs c.1 mm long; styles substraight, c.2.5 mm long (Fig. 10C).
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan, Sichuan, E and S Xizang), Nepal, Bhutan,
North India (Sikkim, Assam) (Fig. 20). In Rhododendron forests and scrub, on grassy
slopes, streamsides, alpine meadows; 2500–5000 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Anemone coelestina was described by Franchet (1885) from
Yunnan as a species close to A. trullifolia but differing from it by the long-ovate
subtrilobed basal leaves, and 5 blue or white petaloids. Although Ulbrich (1906) and
Handel-Mazzetti (1931, 1939) recognized Anemone coelestina as a species, other
authors (e.g. Brühl, 1896; Finet & Gagnepain, 1904; Lauener, 1960; Wang, 1974,
1980; Chaudhary, 1988) regarded this taxon as a subspecies or variety of A.
trullifolia, or included it in A. trullifolia as a synonym. After a comparative
examination of many specimens we note that Anemone trullifolia and A. coelestina
share important characters but that A. coelestina differs from A. trullifolia in having
mostly undivided, oblong-linear to oblanceolate basal leaf blades with wider petioles
(3–5 and 8–10 mm), undivided bracts, solitary flowers, fewer monomorphic petaloids
(5–6 only as compared with 5–15 in A. trullifolia) without anastomosing veins, and
linear filaments. Consequently, we recognize Anemone coelestina as a distinct species.
Brühl (1896) described Anemone obtusiloba subsp. trullifolia var. linearis on the basis
of its linear entire basal leaf blades. Handel-Mazzetti (1939) also recognized this
variety and published it as Anemone trullifolia var. linearis (Brühl) Hand.-Mazz. This
variety was also recognized by Lauener (1960) who assumed its proximity to
Anemone coelestina. As a result of our examination of the type specimens of var.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
81
linearis (Pratt 493 in K and BM) and var. souliei (Soulie 7 in K) we note their
similarity in the basal leaves with short wide petioles and undivided oblong-linear
blades, undivided bracts, solitary flowers, and petaloids without anastomosing veins.
Accordingly, we recognize only one variety (var. linearis). However, we believe this
variety to be closer to Anemone coelestina than to A. trullifolia and include it under
A. coelestina. Variety holophylla Diels was also described under Anemone trullifolia
but was transferred to A. coelestina (Handel-Mazzetti, 1939). Nevertheless, Lauener
(1960) and Wang (1974, 1980) included var. holophylla in Anemone trullifolia.
However, as a result of our examination of the type material of var. holophylla
(Forrest 2166 in BM, E, K) with its lanceolate, almost entire apically toothed basal
leaf blades, and blue-violet petaloids without anastomosing veins, we regard these
plants as closer to Anemone coelestina than to A. trullifolia, and thus transfer var.
holophylla from A. trullifolia to A. coelestina.
Key to varieties
1a. Leaf blades subtrilobed, ovate-oblong; petaloids bluish-white, anastomosing
veins solitary; staminodes absent ______________________ 8a. var. coelestina
1b. Leaf blades undivided or rarely obscurely 3-lobed, linear to oblanceolate;
petaloids bluish-violet, anastomosing veins absent; staminodes absent or
sometimes present _________________________________________________ 2
2a. Leaf blades linear, margins acutely dentate; staminodes absent 8b. var. linearis
2b. Leaf blades oblanceolate, margins obtusely dentate; staminodes sometimes
present ____________________________________________ 8c. var. holophylla
8a. var. coelestina
Leaf blades subtrilobed, ovate-oblong. Petaloids bluish-white, anastomosing veins
solitary; staminodes absent.
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan, Sichuan) (Fig. 20). In alpine meadows and
bushes; 3500–4800 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. Yunnan: sommet du mont Hee-chan-men, environs
de Ta-li, 11 vii 1883, Delavay 3 (P, WU); Mts. Koua-la-po, prei Ho-Kin, env. De Bali, 26 v
1884, Delavay 1853 (P); Mt. Hee Chang men, above Lang-Kong, 2 vi 1884, Delavay 48 (WU);
30 x 1884, Delavay 1034 (WU); Lang-Kong, 16 iv 1887, Delavay s.n. (LE, PE, WU); Lao
Kouy-Chan, pres My Le, 1906, Ngueou 607 (E); Yangtze Watershed, slopes of Likiang Snow
Range, v 1910, Forrest 5640 (BM, K); Lichiang Range, 10–11000 ft, vi 1913, Forrest 10135
(BM); Xiao Huadinba, above farm, 18 v 1981, SBEC 747 (E). SW Sichuan: Mts. Liukuliandse, between Yenyuen and Castle Kwapi, 18 v 1914, Handel-Mazzetti 2437 (WU);
Yungning, 16 vi 1914, Handel-Mazzetti 3085 (WU); Mts. Kopati, Djago and Muli, vi 1928,
Rock 16162 (LE); Mts. Mitsuga, West of Muli Gomba, 4875 m, vi 1928, Rock 16206 (E, K).
8b. var. linearis (Brühl) Ziman & B.E.Dutton, Fl. China 6: 325 (2001). – Anemone
obtusiloba subsp. trullifolia (Hook.f. & Thoms.) Brühl var. linearis Brühl, Ann.
82
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
F I G . 11. Anemone coelestina var. linearis (Brühl) Ziman & B.E.Dutton. A, basal leaf; B,
flower parts (a, stamen; b, carpel) (A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
Roy. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 77 (1896). – Anemone trullifolia var. linearis (Brühl)
Hand.-Mazz., Acta Horti Gothob. 13: 178 (1939). – Type: West Szechuan and
Tibetan Frontier, chiefly near Ta chien Lu, 9–13000 ft, xii 1890, Pratt 493 (holo
BM!). Fig. 11.
Anemone souliei Franch., Bull. Soc. Bot. France 32: 4 (1885). – Anemone trullifolia
Hook.f. & Thoms. var. souliei (Franch.) Finet & Gagnep., Bull. Soc. Bot. France
51: 62 (1904). – Type: Chine. Prov. Se-tchuen, Tongolo, pres Ta-tsien-lou, vii–viii
1891, Soulie 7 (holo P!).
Leaf blades mostly undivided (rarely obscurely 3-lobed), linear, acutely dentate, 8–15
6 2–3 cm. Petaloid anastomosing veins absent. Staminodes absent.
Distribution and habitat. China (NW Yunnan, W and S Sichuan, Xizang), Bhutan
(Fig. 20). In Rhododendron forests and bushes, and in alpine meadows; 2800–4900 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. Yunnan: 1930, Forrest 28855 (E); vii 1935, W.T.
Wang (PE). Sichuan: Tibetan Frontier, chiefly near Ta chien Lu, 9–13000 ft, xii 1890, Pratt 493
(BM); Tongolo, pres Ta-tsien-lou, vii–viii 1891, Soulie 7 (P!); Hongyuan Co., Rangkouxing, 1 viii
1982, Zhao Qing Sheng 212 (E); Chazhenliangzi, 3700 m, 31 vii 1989, Zhao Qing Sheng 14 (E).
Xizang: Pasho Distr., Kham, Valley of Du Chu, 14000 ft, 13 vii 1936, Hanbury-Tracy 30 (BM).
BHUTAN. Chojo Dzong, 13500 ft, 30 vi 1949, Ludlow et al. 16687 (K).
8c. var. holophylla (Diels ex H.F.Comber) Ziman & B.E.Dutton, Fl. China 6: 324
(2001). – Anemone trullifolia Hook.f. & Thoms. var. holophylla Diels, Notes Roy.
Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 5: 263 (1912). – Type: China: Yunnan, Eastern flank of the
Lichiang Range, 3050–3350 m, v 1906, Forrest 2166 (lecto E!; iso BM, K!). Fig. 12.
Anemone coelestina Franch. var. polygyna H.F.Comber and f. holophylla (Diels)
H.F.Comber, Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 27: 226 (1934).
Leaf blades oblanceolate, margins obtusely dentate. Petaloid anastomosing veins
absent. Staminodes sometimes present.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
83
F I G . 12. Anemone coelestina var. holophylla (Diels ex H.F.Comber) Ziman & B.E.Dutton. A,
basal leaf; B, flower parts (a, stamen; b, carpel) (A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
Distribution and habitat. China (NW Yunnan, Sichuan, Xizang), Nepal, North India
(Assam) (Fig. 20). In Rhododendron forests and on grassy slopes; 2500–4900 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. Yunnan: Likiang Range, v 1906, Forrest 2166 (BM,
E); ibid., vi 1906, Forrest 2226 (BM); ibid., vii 1906, Forrest 2634 (E); Distr. Chung-tien, 13000 ft,
Mts. West of Hsiao Chung-tien, v 1932, Rock 24664 (BM, K); Pei Ma Shan, Mekong-Jangtze
Divide, SW of Atuntze, vi 1932, Rock 22764 (BM, K); Haba Shan, North of Yangtze loop,
third Peak of Likiang Snow Range, 1932, Rock 24793 (BM, K). Sichuan: Hongyuan Co.,
Rangkouxiang, 3740 m, 31 vii 1989, Zhao Qing-Sheng 212 (BM); Hongyuan Co., Chazhen
liangzi, 3700 m, 31 vii 1989, Zhao Qing-Sheng 14 (BM). Xizang: 1906, Forrest 362 (K); TafsiculiDaevo, 25 vi 1914, Shimprift 1797 (WU); Hills of Lhasa, 14000 ft, 26 vii 1943, Ludlow & Sheriff
9701 (BM).
NEPAL. East Nepal: Tamur Valley: Mewa Khola, Topke Gola, 13500 ft, 14 v 1956, Stainton
262 (BM, E).
INDIA. Assam: Mago, 11700 ft, 1935, Kingdon-Ward (BM); Chumbi and Phari, 1878,
Dunboo s.n. (BM).
9. Anemone subindivisa W.T.Wang, Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 173 (1974). – Type:
China, Szechuan, Muli, Mons Misuga, 3700–4000 m, 26 v 1937, T.T. Yu 5756
(holo PE!). Figs 13, 21.
Leaves 3–7; petioles 2.5–4 cm 6 5–10 mm, villous; blades undivided or obscurely 3lobed, broadly ovate or orbicular-ovate, 3–4 6 2–3 cm, villous; bases roundedtruncate; margins obtusely dentate, apices rounded (Fig. 13A). Scapes 2–5, 3–10 cm
long, villous; flowers solitary. Involucral bracts entire or subequally 3-dentate,
lanceolate, 1–2 cm long, with obtuse apices, villous. Pedicels 0.5–1 cm long, villous.
Petaloids 5–6, white, broadly elliptic, 8–12 6 5–8 mm, sparsely puberulent, basal
veins 3–5, without anastomoses. Stamens 3–5 mm long; filaments lanceolate (Fig.
13Ba). Carpels 3–3.5 mm long, densely pubescent (Fig. 13Bb).
Distribution and habitat. China. Endemic to SW Sichuan: Muli (Fig. 21). In Abies
and Pinus forests and on grassy slopes; 2500–4000 m.
84
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
F I G . 13. Anemone subindivisa W.T.Wang. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a, stamen; b, carpel)
(A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
Taxonomic remarks. Wang (1974) described this species from China (Sichuan) as
very close to Anemone trullifolia but differing from it by the rounded-truncate basal
leaf bases and mainly undivided blades. Our data confirm that Anemone subindivisa
is a member of series Trullifoliae but we suggest it is closer to A. yulongshanica,
differing from it by its undivided basal leaf blades, wider petioles, entire (sometimes
3-dentate) lanceolate involucral bracts, and smaller petaloids. We accept this taxon
as a species but we note the necessity for further detailed study, especially of its
mature achenes.
Known only from the type collection and a few specimens collected in the same area
and cited in the protologue.
10. Anemone yulongshanica W.T.Wang, Bull. Bot. Res. NE Forest Univ. 16: 159
(1996). – Type: China, Yunnan, Likiang Snow Range, 1937, T.T. Yu 15595 (holo
PE!). Figs 14, 21.
Leaves 5–9; petioles 4–13 cm 6 2–3 mm, pubescent or densely villous; blades 3parted or 3-lobed, pentagonal or broadly ovate, 1–5.5 6 1–6 cm, herbaceous or
F I G . 14. Anemone yulongshanica W.T.Wang var. yulongshanica. A, basal leaf; B, achene (A,
Flora of China, 2001; B, T.T. Yu 1559, PE).
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
85
papery, pubescent or villous, bases truncate; apical lobes 3-lobed or undivided,
rhombic-ovate or broadly rhombic, sparsely obtusely dentate; lateral lobes unequally
2-lobed, obliquely broadly cuneate or flabellate (Fig. 14A). Scapes 2–9, 3–15(–30) cm,
villous or pubescent; flowers solitary. Involucral bracts unequally 3-parted or 3-lobed,
narrowly rhombic or oblong-lanceolate, 0.7–3 cm long, pubescent. Pedicels 1–7 cm
long, puberulent. Petaloids 5–6, white, yellowish or bluish, narrowly obovate or
elliptic, 8–16 6 8–10 mm, sparsely appressed pubescent, basal veins 3, without
anastomosing veins. Stamens 2–3 mm long; filaments lanceolate. Carpels 2.5–3.5 mm
long, linear-lanceolate or narrowly ovoid, sericeous or pubescent. Achenes ovoid, 2.8–
3.7 6 1.8–2.2 mm, without ribs, villous, hairs c.1 mm long; styles 1.4–1.6 mm long,
straight or slightly curved (Fig. 14B).
Distribution and habitat. China (NW Yunnan, SW Sichuan) (Fig. 21). In Abies
forests, on rocks and grassy slopes; 2600–3900 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Diels (1912) noted that certain plants referable to Anemone
trullifolia had basal leaves with truncate bases. However, Comber (1934) later
regarded these variants as belonging to Anemone coelestina, not A. trullifolia.
Moreover, Comber described them as A. coelestina var. truncata and var. polygyna
(the latter with more carpels), and he considered that both varieties were close to A.
coelestina var. holophylla. Eventually Wang (1996) described Anemone yulongshanica
on the basis of a specimen of A. obtusiloba from Yunnan collected by T. T. Yu. It
differs from Anemone obtusiloba s.str. mainly by the apical lobes of the basal leaves
(3-lobed or undivided). According to our data Anemone yulongshanica has certain
affinities to series Obtusilobae but should be regarded as a member of series Trullifoliae.
It differs from Anemone trullifolia by the basally truncate or subcordate (not attenuate)
basal leaf blades, narrower filaments, and smaller ovoid achenes with shorter styles.
Wang (1974) divided this species into two varieties, with var. yulongshanica differing
from var. truncata mostly by its larger basal leaves and bracts. Wang et al. (2001)
maintained these varieties and both are recognized in this treatment.
Key to varieties
1a. Basal leaf petioles 6–13 cm long, pubescent; leaf blades 3–5.5 6 4–6 cm, basally
subcordate, apical lobes 3-cleft; involucral bracts 1.5–3 cm long; carpels linearlanceolate, sericeous _____________________________ 10a. var. yulongshanica
1b. Basal leaf petioles 4–5 cm long, densely villous; leaf blades 1–3.5 6 1–4 cm,
basally truncate, apical lobes undivided; involucral bracts 0.7–2 cm long; carpels
narrowly ovoid, pubescent ____________________________ 10b. var. truncata
10a. var. yulongshanica
Basal leaf petioles 6–13 cm long, pubescent; leaf blades 3–5.5 6 4–6 cm, basally
subcordate, apical lobes 3-cleft (Fig. 14A). Involucral bracts 1.5–3 cm long. Carpels
linear-lanceolate, sericeous (Fig. 14B).
86
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
F I G . 15. Anemone yulongshanica var. truncata (H.F.Comber) W.T.Wang. A, basal leaf; B,
flower parts (a, stamen; b, carpel) (A–B, Flora of China, 2001).
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan). Endemic to the Lichiang Snow Range.
Known only from the type collection.
10b. var. truncata (H.F.Comber) W.T.Wang, Bull. Bot. Res. NE Forest Univ. 16:
159 (1996). – Anemone coelestina Franch. var. truncata H.F.Comber, Notes Roy.
Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 18: 226 (1934). – Type: China, Yunnan, East flank of
Lichiang Range, 11000 ft, v 1910, Forrest 5640 (holo E!; iso K!, P!). Fig. 15.
Basal leaf petioles 4–5 cm long, densely villous; leaf blades 1–3.5 6 1–4 cm, basally
truncate, apical lobes undivided (Fig. 15A). Involucral bracts 0.7–2 cm long. Carpels
narrowly ovoid, pubescent (Fig. 15Bb).
Distribution. China (Yunnan). Endemic to the Lichiang Snow Range.
Known only from the type collection.
11. Anemone rupestris Wall. ex Hook.f. & Thoms., Fl. Ind. 1: 21 (1855). – Type:
Sikkim, 4570 m, Hooker s.n. (lecto K!; iso E!). Figs 16, 21.
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. lobata Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78 (1896).
– Type: Sikkim: on the Pa-Tang-La; Chumbi, at Ley-rong, King’s collector (iso
CAL).
Anemone rupestris Wall. ex Hook.f. & Thoms. var. wallichii Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard.
Calcutta 5: 78 (1896). – Type: Nepal, Gossain Than, Wallich 4696 (holo CAL; iso
K).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. saxicola Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78
(1896). – Anemone saxicola (Brühl) Tamura & Kitamura in Kihara, Fauna Fl.
Nepal. Himal. 125 (1955). – Type: Kashmir, Falconer 28 (holo CAL).
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. omalocarpella Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5:
78 (1896). – Type: Nipal, Scully (holo CAL).
Anemone bhutanica Tamura, Acta Phytotax. Geobot. 19: 75 (1962). – Type: Bhutan,
Shukuna Mountain, 1 viii 1958, Nakao 101 (holo KYO).
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
87
F I G . 16. Anemone rupestris Wall. ex Hook.f. & Thoms. subsp. rupestris. A, basal leaf; B,
flower parts (a, petaloid; b, stamens; c, carpel); C, achene (A–B, Ludlow & Sheriff 20352, E; C,
Handel-Mazzetti 1914, WU).
Basal leaves 4–7; petioles 3–10 6 1–2 mm, sparsely puberulent or subglabrous;
blades twice 3-sect, ovate, 1–5 6 1–6 cm, sparsely puberulent or glabrous, bases
subcordate; apical leaflets with petiolules 5–10 mm long, 3-sect or 3-parted, broadly
rhombic, secondary leaflets with petiolules 1–2 mm long, ultimate lobules narrowly
ovate or linear-lanceolate; lateral leaflets on petiolules 2–5 mm or subsessile, 3parted or 3-lobed, subreniform (Fig. 16A). Scapes 2–6, 3–20 cm long, sparsely
puberulent or subglabrous, 1–3-flowered. Involucral bracts undivided or 2- or 3lobed, ovate-oblong, cuneate-obovate or rhombic, 1–3 cm long. Pedicels 1–6 cm
long, puberulent or glabrous. Petaloids 5–6(–8), white, blue or purplish or reddishwhite, oblong-elliptic or obovate, mainly dimorphic (outer and inner ones differ in
size and colour), 5–10(–14) 6 3–6(–8) mm, subglabrous, basal veins, anastomosing
veins absent (Fig. 16Ba). Stamens 3.5–4.3 mm long; filaments lanceolate or oblongelliptic (Fig. 16Bb). Carpels ovoid, compressed, 2.5–3.3 mm long, subglabrous; styles
down-curved (Fig. 16Bc). Achenes broadly ellipsoid, compressed, 2.5–4 6 1.6–2 mm,
subglabrous; ribs distinct; styles curved, sometimes basally bent, 1.2–1.8 mm long
(Fig. 16C).
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan, Sichuan, S Xizang, Sikang), Nepal,
Bhutan, India (Sikkim, Assam, Kashmir) (Fig. 21). In Rhododendron bushes, alpine
meadows and on rocky outcrops; 2700–4800 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Anemone rupestris was described (Hooker & Thomson, 1855) as
a taxon very close to A. obtusiloba but with smaller and more slender 1–3-flowered
stems, with narrower segments to the more dissected leaves and is less hairy. Later,
Hooker (1872) assumed this taxon to be a part of Anemone obtusiloba and not a
88
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
distinct species. Maximowicz (1890) described Anemone gelida on the basis of its
twice 3-sect basal leaves, 3-lobed or entire bracts, 6–8 glabrous petaloid sepals and
compressed pilose achenes with short straight styles. Shortly afterwards Brühl (1896)
proposed to reduce Anemone gelida to a subspecies of A. rupestris due to the overall
similarity except for the number and colour of petaloids and the pubescent
receptacle. He recognized within Anemone rupestris three varieties: var. lobata, var.
wallichii and var. pusilla. More recently, other authors (Ulbrich, 1906; Lauener,
1960) included Anemone gelida as a subspecies of A. rupestris. Thus, according to
Lauener, Anemone rupestris includes two subspecies, subsp. rupestris and subsp.
gelida, the latter with two varieties, var. gelida and var. wallichii. On the other hand,
Wang (1974, 1980) and Chaudhary (1988) both regarded Anemone rupestris as
consisting of three subspecies: subsp. rupestris, subsp. gelida and subsp. polycarpa.
After a comparative study of Anemone rupestris and A. gelida, we confirm their
similarity, but differentiate A. gelida by its smaller basal leaves, scapes, petaloids,
and strictly solitary flowers. Consequently, following Wang et al. (2001), we
accept Anemone rupestris and A. gelida as subspecies. In contrast, the characters
listed by Brühl (1896) to separate three varieties appear to be too variable and not
sufficiently distinct to warrant the recognition of the varieties. The same applies
to the varieties of Anemone rupestris subsp. gelida (Lauener, 1960). Recently we
included Anemone obtusiloba D.Don subsp. omalocarpella Brühl as a synonym of
A. polycarpa (Wang et al., 2001), but here we reject this opinion and accept it as a
part of A. rupestris due to its ‘nearly flat, margined, quite glabrous carpels’ (Brühl,
1896: 78).
Key to subspecies
1a. Leaf blades 2–5 6 1–6 cm; scapes 10–20 cm long, 1–3-flowered; petaloids 5–6,
8–10(–14) 6 4–6(–8) mm; flowers and achenes subglabrous ________________
__________________________________________________ 11a. subsp. rupestris
1b. Leaf blades 1–1.5 6 1–2 cm; scapes 3–12 cm long, 1-flowered; petaloids 5–8, 5–7
6 3–4 mm; flowers and achenes glabrous _______________ 11b. subsp. gelida
11a. subsp. rupestris
Leaf blades 2–5 6 1–6 cm. Scapes 10–20 cm long, 1–3-flowered. Petaloids 5–6, 8–
10(–14) 6 4–6(–8) mm. Flowers and achenes subglabrous (Fig. 16).
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan, Sichuan, Xizang), Nepal, Bhutan, North
India (Fig. 21). On slopes and along streams; 2500–3000 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. Yunnan: Pei-ma shan, ix 1932, Rock 23390 (GH);
Yangtze Watershed, western slopes of Likiang Snow Range, 6 vi 1922, Rock 4219 (BM).
Sichuan: Yunghing, 24 vi 1914, Handel-Mazzetti s.n. (WU). SE Xizang: Tsarung, northern
slopes of Mt. Kenichunpo, North of Sikitung, Upper Salween River, v 1932, Rock 22179 (E,
K); Shinden-Gompa, Nagong, 25 vii 1933, Kingdon-Ward 10641 (BM); Kongbo Prov., Lusha
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
89
Chu, 12000 ft, 9 vi 1938, Ludlow & Sheriff 4723 (BM); 60 km North of Lhasa, Reting, 14000 ft,
27 vi 1944, Ludlow & Sheriff 11069 (BM).
NEPAL. Gosainsthan, Gopain Shar, Wallich 4696 (K); Arun Valley, Chhoyang Khola, West
of Num, 13000 ft, 22 vi 1956, Stainton 739 (E).
BHUTAN. Me La, 9 vi 1949, Ludlow & Sheriff 20352 (E); Kangla Karcha La, Po Chu
Drainage, 16000 ft, 20 vi 1949, Ludlow & Sheriff 16596 (E).
INDIA. Sikkim: Hills to North and West of Dzongri camp, 4200 m, 23 vi 1983, Starling et al.
82 (E); West Distr., between Dzongri and Black Kabru (Kabur), 4050 m, 17 vii 1992, Long
et al. 450 (E); Kashmir, 15000 ft, alpine belt, 1864, Falconer s.n. (K); Sikkim, 4570 m, Hooker
s.n. (E, K); Sikkim, Himalaya, 15000 ft, 1832, Wallich 4676 (K), 5479 (K); Kashmir ad Pir
Panjal, Jacquemont s.n. (K).
11b. subsp. gelida (Maxim.) Lauener, Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 23: 199
(1960). – Anemone gelida Maxim., Acta Hort. Petropol. 11: 21 (1890). – Type:
China, S Sichuan, Valle Kserntso, 11 viii 1885, Potanin s.n. (holo LE!; iso K!).
Fig. 17.
Anemone obtusiloba D.Don var. pusilla Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78 (1896).
– Type: Sikkim, Sei-Cho-La, W of Jongri; Kapur below Kinchinjanga; Pandimchu, 15000 ft, King’s collectors s.n. (iso CAL!).
Leaf blades 1–1.5 6 1–2 cm. Scapes 3–12 cm long, 1-flowered. Petaloids 5–8, 5–7 6
3–4 mm. Flowers and achenes glabrous.
Distribution and habitat. China (Yunnan, Sichuan, Xizang), Bhutan, Nepal, India
(Fig. 21). In alpine meadows; 4800–5000 m.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. NW Yunnan: Lu-djiang (Salween) and Djiou-djiang
(Irrawadi), close to Tschiangschel, 4075 m, 4 vii 1916, Handel-Mazzetti 9262 (WU), 2730
(WU); Yangtze Watershed, western slopes of Likiang Snow Range, 6 vi 1922, Rock 4219 (E);
F I G . 17. Anemone rupestris subsp. gelida (Maxim.) Lauener. A, basal leaf; B, flower parts (a,
petaloid; b, stamen; c, carpel) (A, Handel-Mazzetti 1658, WU; B, Potanin 1885, LE).
90
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
SW of Wei-Hsi, Mekong-Salween Divide, 4300 m, v 1928, Rock 16965 (K). SW Sichuan:
Daliang-schan (territory Lolo), East of Nirgyuen, close Lauba, 2700 m, 25 iv 1914, HandelMazzetti 1658 (WU).
BHUTAN. Shimitang, Bumthang Co., 10500 ft, 23 v 1949, Ludlow & Sheriff 18940 (BM).
NEPAL. Dhimti Shir, 14000 ft, 1930, Lall Dhwoj 487 (BM); Lete: South of Tukucha, Kali
Gandaki, 12500 ft, 7 vi 1954, Stainton et al. 1012 (BM); Bhurungdi Khola, 10000 ft, 15 vi 1954,
Stainton et al. 5798 (BM); Rambrong, Lamjung Himal, 13500 ft, 5 vii 1954, Stainton et al.
6154 (BM); Inkhu Khola, 14000 ft, 17 vi 1964, Bowes-Lyon 2044 (BM); Dudh Kosi:
Chaunrikharka, 13000 ft, 20 vi 1964, Bowes-Lyon 2087 (BM); Likhu Khola: East of
Chaukharma, 12500 ft, McCosh 250 (BM).
INDIA. Sikkim: Hills to North and West Dzongri camp site, 4200 m, 23 vi 1983, Starling et al.
82 (E).
The remaining two species, Anemone imbricata Maxim. and A. fuscopurpurea
H.Hara, described and discussed below, are rather isolated members of Anemone
subgen. Omalocarpus but have sometimes been considered to belong to Anemone
sect. Himalayicae. Until more information is available we prefer to exclude them
from this section.
12. Anemone imbricata Maxim., Fl. Tangut. 8 (1889). – Anemone obtusiloba D.Don
subsp. imbricata (Maxim.) Brühl, Ann. Bot. Gard. Calcutta 5: 78 (1896). – Type:
China, S Tibet, Jangtze, 1884, Przewalski (E!, LE!).
Leaves 4–7; petioles basally vaginate, 3–5 6 0.1–0.2 cm, villous; blades appear
pinnatifid but are in principle 3-sect, elliptic-ovate, 2–3 6 1.2–2 cm, villous; bases
cordate; central segments on petiolules 5–10 mm long, 3-sect or 3-parted; lateral
segments shortly petiolulate or subsessile, unequally 3-parted; segments and lobes
imbricate. Scapes 3–5(–10), 5–12 cm long, villous; cymes 1–2-flowered. Involucral
bracts with 3-parted or 3-lobed blades, 1–2 cm long, villous. Pedicels 1–3.5 cm long,
villous. Petaloids 5–7(–9), obovate-oblong or obovate, with acute apices, purple or
blackish-purple (rarely whitish), sometimes dimorphic, 8–13 6 4–8 cm, glabrous or
sparsely puberulent only along central veins; basal veins 3, without anastomoses.
Stamens 3–5 mm long; filaments linear, slightly dilated; anthers ellipsoid. Carpels
broadly ovate, 2.5–3 mm long, glabrous. Achenes broadly elliptic, 4.5–6 6 3–4 mm,
glabrous, compressed, with ribs 0.5–0.7 mm wide; styles basally bent, c.1 mm long.
Distribution and habitat. China (W Sichuan, SW Gansu, Qinghai, E Xinjang,
Xizang). In bushes and on grassy slopes; 3200–5300 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Maximowicz (1889), who described Anemone imbricata, noted
its pinnatifid basal leaf blades and long-vaginate dilated petioles, 3-lobed involucral
bracts, solitary flowers with 5–9 violet ‘sepals’, dilated stamens, and compressed
glabrous achenes with conic-cylindric styles. Among students of the Anemone
obtusiloba complex only Brühl (1896) lumped A. imbricata with A. obtusiloba,
whereas Ulbrich (1906), Lauener (1960) and Wang (1974, 1980, etc.) recognized A.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
91
imbricata as a distinct species. Most authors regarded Anemone imbricata as a
member of the A. obtusiloba complex but Starodubtsev (1991) made this species the
type of a new section: Anemonastrum sect. Imbricata.
As a result of our comparative study of Anemone imbricata and examination of the
Przewalski type material (in LE and E) we suggest that this taxon does not belong to
sections Himalayicae (Anemone obtusiloba complex) or Omalocarpus but should be
placed in a monotypic section Imbricata of Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus.
Selection of herbarium specimens. CHINA. Yunnan: Kunming, Dijing Pref., Degin Co., Bai Ma
Shan, N of W Pass, 4530 m, vi 1993, Alden et al. 818 (E). SW Sichuan: Kulu Mts., Muli
Territory, 15000 ft, Rock 23953 (BM), 23955 (BM); Djesi-La and Djesi-Longba, S of
Tatsienlu, vi 1929, Forrest 12704 (K). Qinghai: Yushu Xian, between Yushu and Gyairong, 9
viii 1996, T.N. Ho et al. 2059 (GH). Xinjang: Kangting (Tanchienlu), Tapaoshan, 4700 m, 22
viii 1934, Smith 11512 (BM); Kuen-Lun, 24 vi 1894, Robowski 362 (LE). Xizang: Jangtze, 1884,
Przewalski (E, LE); Russkoe Lake, 2 vi 1901, Ladygin 87 (LE); between Radja and Jupar,
Wajo la, vi 1926, Rock 14146 (LE); Totuch Nira, 14300 ft, vii 1926, Rock 14371 (K); Alpine
Region between Radja and Jupar Range, Wotila, 14500 ft, vi 1929, Rock 14231 (K); Nang La,
20 vi 1936, Ludlow & Sheriff 1840 (BM); N of Lhasa, 15000 ft, 24 vi 1942, Ludlow & Sheriff
8737 (BM); NW of Lhasa, Nyenchentang La, 10 vi 1943, Ludlow & Sheriff 9604 (BM).
13. Anemone fuscopurpurea H.Hara, J. Jap. Bot. 48: 353 (1973). – Type: E Nepal,
Banduke pokhari Saju pokhari, 4200 m, 15 vi 1972, Kanai et al. 721252 (holo TI!;
iso E!).
Leaves 5–7; petioles 5–10 cm long, sparsely puberulent; blades 3-sect, rounded-ovate,
2–3 6 2–4 cm, glabrous, ciliate; segments subsessile; central segments 3-lobed,
oblong-rhombic; bases cuneate; margins incised-dentate; lateral segments similar to
central ones, but smaller. Scapes 2–4, mainly ascending, 5–15 cm long, basally
villous; cymes 2–5-flowered. Involucral bracts 3-lobed, bases cuneate, margins dentate,
2–3 cm long, sparsely puberulent. Pedicels 4–5 cm long, villous. Petaloids 4–5, purple,
oblong, basally narrowed, apically rounded, 6–10 6 2–5 mm, puberulent; basal
veins 3–5, vein anastomoses 1–3. Stamens 2–2.5 mm long; filaments slightly dilated;
anthers oblong. Carpels ovate, glabrous, styles curved, c.1 mm long. Data on achenes
lacking.
Distribution and habitat. East Nepal (Pokhari, Topke Gola); 3600–4400 m.
Taxonomic remarks. Anemone fuscopurpurea was described (Hara, 1973) from the
flora of the Himalaya (East Nepal) on the basis of several herbarium specimens
without achenes. Hara regarded this taxon as close to both Anemone obtusiloba (sect.
Himalayicae) and A. demissa (sect. Omalocarpus). Tarasevich & Chaudhary (1987)
examined its pollen grains and placed Anemone fuscopurpurea in a monotypic section
Fuscopurpurea. Based on a morphological study of the herbarium material available
in E we suggest its affinities are to section Omalocarpus. Until more SEM data
become available on the microsculpture of pollen grains from other members of
subgenus Omalocarpus and until the fruits of Anemone fuscopurpurea can be studied,
92
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
we prefer to exclude this species from section Himalayicae and maintain it in section
Omalocarpus rather than describe a separate section.
Specimens examined. NEPAL. Arun-Tamur, Topke Gola, 13500 ft, 11 v 1956, Stainton 253 (E);
Topke Gola, 14000 ft, 4 vii 1971, Beer 8280 (E!).
D ISCUSSION: O RIGIN AND E CO-GEOGRAPHICAL R ADIATION
A NEMONE SECT. H IMALAYICAE
OF
The close affinities between Anemone sect. Himalayicae and sect. Omalocarpus, both
accommodated within Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus, are supported not only by the
numerous apomorphic morphological characters they share (see earlier), but also by
their karyotype and chromosome base number x 5 7. This number can be derived by
several structural changes from the basic karyotype of x 5 8, plesiomorphic for
Anemoninae (Baumberger, 1970). That members of Anemone sect. Himalayicae are
characterized by this apomorphic x 5 7 has been obscured by earlier, clearly
erroneous counts of 2n 5 16 (e.g. Sobti & Singh, 1961). These have now been
superseded by several more careful recent studies which have clearly shown n 5 7 or
2n 5 14 for Anemone obtusiloba (Bhattarai, 1989; further references in Starodubtsev,
1989), A. geum (5 A. obtusiloba subsp. ovalifolia; Yang & Wu, 1993; Huang et al.,
1996) and A. trullifolia (Sarkar et al., 1978). Members of Anemone sect. Omalocarpus
and sect. Himalayicae are apparently diploid throughout and no polyploidy has yet
been recorded for this clade.
Furthermore, Hoot et al. (1994) have presented very well-supported evidence from
chloroplast DNA restriction analyses for the close relationships of Anemone
narcissiflora and A. demissa (Anemone sect. Omalocarpus), and of A. obtusiloba and
A. trullifolia (Anemone sect. Himalayicae). Available cladograms suggest a narrow
sister relationship of the two species groups within a clearly separated major clade
corresponding to the present Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus. This, in turn, is
affiliated to a major clade of the genus Anemone s.l., characterized by the
chromosome base number x 5 7. Thus, the former placement of Anemone sect.
Himalayicae under the genus or section Pulsatilloides (with x 5 8; far from
Omalocarpus), maintained until quite recently (e.g. Starodubtsev, 1991), is now
definitively refuted.
The affinities between members of Anemone sect. Omalocarpus and sect.
Himalayicae are so close that their taxonomic separation still suffers from
uncertainties. Fruit characters of Anemone rupestris (sole species of Anemone sect.
Himalayicae ser. Rupestres) tend towards Anemone sect. Omalocarpus. Furthermore,
the placement of two critical and also rather isolated species, Anemone fuscopurpurea
H.Hara and A. imbricata Maxim., is still under dispute. They are put either into
Anemone sect. Omalocarpus or into monotypic sections of their own (see earlier).
This makes further studies on the alliance of Anemone subgen. Omalocarpus
necessary.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
93
Members of Anemone sect. Himalayicae differ from those of Anemone sect.
Omalocarpus predominantly with respect to derived, apomorphic characters which
often can be interpreted as adaptations to high-montane or alpine habitats. This
supports the hypothesis that Anemone sect. Himalayicae originated, possibly during
the late Tertiary, Pleistocene and Postglacial eras, as a response to the lifting of the
Himalayan, Tibetan and SW Chinese mountain systems (see Rowley et al., 2001,
etc.), from Anemone sect. Omalocarpus-like ancestors growing at lower elevations.
What can be said about the further morphological and eco-geographical
differentiation within Anemone sect. Himalayicae? On comparison of taxa from
Anemone ser. Rupestres with ser. Obtusilobae and finally with ser. Trullifoliae with
respect to vegetative features, we can demonstrate a decrease in leaf size, a reduction
in leaf division, an increasing fusion of leaflets combined with loss of petiolules, and
an increase in the density of the indumentum. Noteworthy among reproductive
features are reductions from several-flowered cymes to solitary flowers, a decrease in
anastomosing veins in petaloids, development of staminodes, dilatation of initially
linear filaments, and changes in the hairiness of petaloids, pistils and fruits. Trends
F I G . 18. Distribution of Anemone obtusiloba.
94
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
relevant for the achenes concern changes from ovoid to compressed, development of
lateral ribs, and transformations of styles from straight to curved, bent or hooked.
Within Anemone sect. Himalayicae, Anemone obtusiloba and A. polycarpa appear to
have numerous plesiomorphic characters. Most other taxa, however, belong to an
intermediate level, whereas Anemone coelestina and A. subindivisa apparently
represent evolutionarily more advanced species.
The taxa of Anemone sect. Himalayicae are concentrated in the mountains of SW
China and the Himalayan ranges of Burma, Bhutan, Nepal and North India. All of
them are high-mountain plants occurring in the cool temperate montane to the
subalpine and alpine belts at 1850–4800 m elevation (Figs 18–21). From Anemone
ser. Obtusilobae the polymorphic A. obtusiloba has reached the widest distribution
area within the section and now extends from SW China (with two endemic
infraspecific taxa) to the Himalaya (with subsp. nepalensis in the central and var.
potentilloides in the western part), Burma, Pakistan, Afghanistan, the mountains of
North China, Kirgizstan and Mongolia (var. obtusiloba which also overlaps with
other infraspecific taxa). It occurs from open forests at lower elevations to scrub at
F I G . 19. Distribution of Anemone patula, A. polycarpa, A. geum and A. subpinnata.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
95
F I G . 20. Distribution of Anemone rockii, A. trullifolia and A. coelestina.
the timberline and to grassland, rocks and talus in alpine regions. Among the other
members of Anemone ser. Obtusilobae, the species A. geum and A. rockii have also
attained large areas of distribution and wide altitudinal ranges. The former reaches
to the western Himalaya and from the mountains of SW China to the eastern
Tienshan in Xinjang. Anemone rockii extends from Sichuan to the central Himalaya.
In contrast, Anemone polycarpa is limited as an ultraoreophyte to altitudes above
3500 m and ranges through the Himalaya to SW China, whereas its close relatives A.
patula and A. subpinnata occur as local endemics in the mountains of Sichuan.
The taxa of Anemone sect. Himalayicae ser. Trullifoliae and ser. Rupestres exhibit a
similar eco-geographical pattern but are more restricted and disjunct in the central
Himalaya and the mountains of SW China. Populations in both areas and with a
wide altitudinal range characterize the Anemone ser. Trullifoliae taxa A. trullifolia
96
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
F I G . 21. Distribution of Anemone yulongshanica, A. subindivisa and A. rupestris.
var. trullifolia and A. coelestina var. holophylla, whereas A. yulongshanica and A.
subindivisa are endemics in SW China. The other taxa of Anemone ser. Trullifoliae
are restricted to high altitudes: A. coelestina var. coelestina and var. linearis occur in
both areas, whereas A. trullifolia var. liangshanica and var. lutienensis have been
found locally in SW China only. The infraspecific differentiation of Anemone
rupestris in the monotypic series Rupestres is comparable: subsp. rupestris occurs at a
relatively wide range of altitudes in the central and eastern Himalaya and adjacent
Tibet, whereas subsp. gelida is an ultraoreophyte with populations in the Himalaya
and the mountains of SW China.
In retrospect, one can conclude that the present eco-geographical distribution of
taxa within Anemone sect. Himalayicae is due to an allopatric pattern of
differentiation. This has apparently followed two parallel trends of expansion: (i)
from the SW Chinese mountains and the eastern and central Himalaya to the
western Himalaya, Afghanistan, the Tienshan and to mountain ranges in NW China
and adjacent central Asia; (ii) from lower to higher and highest mountain regions.
Comparable examples for an allopatric east/west differentiation along the Himalaya
are afforded by the Galium serpylloides group (Rubiaceae–Rubieae: SchönbeckTemesy & Ehrendorfer, 1987) and many other taxa. Within Anemone sect.
Himalayicae the highest concentration of local endemic taxa (seven) is found in
SW China, whereas only one other endemic is documented for the central Himalaya.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
97
In most regions of the distribution area of the section more than one taxon has been
found. Future field work should clarify if there is isolation between these taxa (due
either to their occurrence in different habitats or to other mechanisms). If there is
none, one has to consider varying degrees of hybridization. In view of the close
affinities of most taxa, their great variability and often difficult separation, such a
scenario appears quite likely.
A CKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are grateful to the curators of the herbaria who provided access to their
collections. Especially helpful were Prof. S. Owens and G. Challen (Royal Botanic
Gardens, Kew), Dr R. Vickerey (Natural History Museum, London), and H. Hoy
(Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh). We are also pleased to thank Dr C. Alexander
(former Senior Editor of Edinburgh Journal of Botany) and D. Middleton (current
Senior Editor) for their valuable advice and suggestions on the manuscript, and O.
Kornienko (Kholodny Institute of Botany, National Academy of Science of
Ukraine, Kiev) for her indispensable technical help in the preparation of our
manuscript.
R EFERENCES
B A U M BE R G E R , H . (1970). Chromosomenzahlbestimmungen und Karyotypanalysen bei den
Gattungen Anemone, Hepatica und Pulsatilla. Ber. Schweiz. Bot. Ges. 80: 17–96.
B HA TTAR AI , S. (1989). Karyomorphological studies in four species of Anemone. Cytologia
54: 709–713.
B RÜ HL , P . (1896). Descriptions of new and rare Indian plants. Ann. Roy. Bot. Gard. Calcutta
5: 76–81.
C HA U DH AR Y , R . P. (1988). A synopsis of the genus Anemone (Ranunculaceae) in Nepal and
the adjacent regions of the Himalaya. Bot. Zhurn. 73: 1188–1202 (in Russian).
C O M B E R , H . F . (1934). Plantae Chinensis Forrestianae. New and imperfectly known species.
Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 18: 226–227.
D E C A N D O L L E , A . P . (1824). Prodromus Systematis Naturalis Regni Vegetabilis. Pars 2.
Parisiis.
D I E L S , L. (1912). Plantae Chinensis Forrestianae. New and imperfectly known species. Notes
Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 5: 263.
D O N , D . (1825). Florae Nepalensis. Londini.
E VAN S , W. E . (1921). Diagnoses species novarum herbario Horti Regii Botanici
Edinburgensis cognitarum. Notes Roy. Bot. Gard. Edinburgh 63–64: 154–155.
F IN E T , A . & G AG N E PA IN , F . (1904). Anemone L. Bull. Soc. Bot. France 51: 56–76.
F RA NCH E T , A. (1885). Plantes du Yun-nan recoltees par M.l’Abbe Delavay. Anemone L.
Bull. Soc. Bot. France 32: 4.
H A ND E L - M A Z Z E T T I , H . (1931). Anemone L. In: Symbolae Sinicae, vol. 7. Wien: Springer
Verlag.
H A ND E L - M A Z Z E T T I , H . (1939). Plantae Sinensis. Acta Horti Gothob. 13: 37–219.
H A RA , H . (1973). New or noteworthy flowering plants from Eastern Himalaya. J. Jap. Bot.
48: 353–359.
H A RA , H . & W IL L IA MS , L. H . J . (1979). Enumeration of the Flowering Plants of Nepal, vol.
2. London: British Museum (Natural History).
98
S. N. ZIMAN ET AL.
H OLM G REN , P. K ., H OL MG REN , N . H . & B A RN E T T , L. C. (1990). Index Herbariorum.
Part I: The Herbaria of the World. 8th edition. Regnum Veg. 120: 1–693.
H OO KE R , J . D . (1872). Anemone L. Flora of British India, vol. 1. London: Recke Co.
H OO KE R , J . D . & T HO MS ON , T. (1855). Anemone L. Flora Indica, vol. 1. London.
H OO T , S. , R E Z N ICE K , A . A . & P ALM E R , J . D . (1994). Phylogenetic relationships in
Anemone (Ranunculaceae) based on morphology and chloroplast DNA. Syst. Bot. 19: 169–200.
H U AN G , R. - F., S H E N , S.- D . & L U , X .- F. (1996). Studies on chromosome number and
polyploidy for a number of plants in the north-east Qinghai-Xizang Plateau. Acta Bot.
Boreal.-Occid. Sin. 16: 310–318.
J AN CZE WSK I , E. (1892). Studium morphologiczne. Etudes morphologiques sur le genre
Anemone. Bull. Acad. Sci. Cracow 4: 1–26.
J U Z E PC HU K , S. V. (1937). Anemone L. In: K O M A R O V , V . L . (ed.) Flora of the U.S.S.R.,
vol. 7. Moscow: Acad. Sci. Publ. (in Russian).
L A UE N E R , L. A . (1960). Notes on Anemone obtusiloba and its allies. Notes Roy. Bot. Gard.
Edinburgh 23: 179–201.
L É V E IL L E , H . (1915). Decades plantarum novarum. XXVI. Anemone L. Bull. Acad. Geogr.
Bot. (Le Mans) 22: 383–384.
L É V E IL L E , H . (1917). Catalogue des plantes de Yun-Nan. Le Mans.
M A XI MO WI CZ , C. J . (1889). Anemone L. Flora Tangutica, Sive Enumeratio, vol. 1. Petropol.
M A XI MO WI CZ , C. J . (1890). Plantae Chinensis Potaninianae. Acta Horti Petropol. 11: 5–34.
P R IT Z E L , G . A . (1841). Anemonarum revisio. Linnaea 15: 561–698.
Q UR ESH I , R . A . & C H AU DH R I , M. N . (1978). Additions to the Flora of Pakistan. I.
Anemone L. Pakistan Syst. 2: 15–16.
Q UR ESH I , R . A . & C H AU DH R I , M. N . (1988). The Ranunculaceae of Pakistan. Pakistan
Syst. 4: 104–120.
R E CH IN G E R , K. H . & R I E D L , H . (1992). Flora des Iranischen Hochlandes und der
Umrahmenden Gebirge, 92. Graz: Akad. Druck.
R IE D L , H. & N A SI R , J . J . (1991). Anemone L. Flora of Pakistan 193: 68–82. Islamabad:
National Herbarium, Pakistan Agricultural Council.
R O W L E Y , D . B ., P I E R R E H U M B E R T , E. T. & C U RRI E , B. S. (2001). A new approach to
stable isotope-based paleoaltimetry: implications for paleoaltimetry and paleohypsometry
of the High Himalaya since the late Miocene. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 5836:
1–17.
S A RK AR , A . K . , D A T T A , N . , M A L L I C K , R . & C H A T T E R J E E , U . (1978). IOPB
chromosome number reports LIX. Taxon 27: 53–55.
S CH Ö N B E C K - T E M E S Y , E. & E H RE N DO RF E R , F . (1987). The vicarious differentiation of
the alpine Galium serpylloides group (Rubiaceae), endemic to the W. Himalaya. Pl. Syst.
Evol. 155: 77–87.
S H AR MA , B. D . , B A L AK R IS HN AN , N . P ., R AO , R . R . & H A J RA , P . K . (1993). Anemone
L. Flora of India, vol. I, pp. 27–41. Calcutta: Botanical Survey of India.
S O B T I , S. N . & S I N GH , S. (1961). A chromosome survey of Indian medicinal plants. Part I.
Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci. B 54: 138–144.
S T A R O D U B T S E V , V. N. (1989). New taxa of the subtribe Anemoninae (Ranunculaceae). Bot.
Zhurn. 74: 1344–1346 (in Russian).
S T A R O D U B T S E V , V. N . (1991). Vetrenitsy. Systematics and evolution. Leningrad: Nauka (in
Russian).
T A MU RA , M. (1967). Morphology, ecology and phylogeny of the Ranunculaceae. VIII. Sci.
Rept. (Osaka Univ.) 17: 21–42.
T A MU RA , M. (1986). Ranunculaceae of Nepal collected by Dr. H. Tabata in 1976 and 1978.
Acta Phytotax. Geobot. 37: 152–160.
REVISION OF ANEMONE SECT. HIMALAYICAE
99
T AM UR A , M . (1991). A new classification of the family Ranunculaceae. 2. Acta Phytotax.
Geobot. 42: 177–187.
T AM UR A , M . (1995). Anemone L. In: E N G L E R , A . & P R A N T L , K . Die Natürlichen
Pflanzenfamilien, V01.17 a IV. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot.
T AR ASE VIC H , V. F. & C H AU DH A RY , R . P. (1987). Palynological study of species of the
genus Anemone (Ranunculaceae) from Nepal in connection with their systematics. Bot.
Zhurn. 72: 887–896 (in Russian).
T HO THA T H RI , K . & U N I YA L , B . P . (1982). Critical notes on Anemone obtusiloba D.Don.
Bull. Bot. Surv. India 24: 106–107.
U L B R I C H , E . (1906). Über die systematische Gliederung und geographische Verbreitung der
Gattung Anemone L. Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 37: 172–334.
U L B R I C H , E. (1929). Anemone rockii. Notizbl. Bot. Gart. Berlin-Dahlem 10: 876.
W AN G , W. T . (1974). Notulae Criticae Sinensibus. Acta Phytotax. Sin. 12: 170–180 (in
Chinese).
W AN G , W . T. (1980). Subtribe Anemoninae Spach. Flora Reipublicae Popularis Sinicae, vol.
28. Peking (in Chinese).
W AN G , W. T. (1996). A new species Anemone yulongshanica W.T.Wang. Bull. Bot. Res. NE
Forest Univ. 16: 159.
W AN G , W. T ., Z I MAN , S . & D U T T O N , B. E. (2001). Anemone L. Flora of China 6:
307–322. Beijing & St Louis: Science Press & Missouri Botanical Garden.
Y A NG , Y .- P. & W U , S. -G . (1993). Chromosomal reports on some plants of Hohxil region,
Qinghai (1). Acta Bot. Yunnan. 15: 173–178.
Received 11 April 2003; accepted for publication 5 December 2006